MONDAY, APRIL 21, 2003 CERTIORARI -- SUMMARY DISPOSITION. The petition for a writ of certiorari is granted.

Transkript

1 (ORDER LIST: 538 U.S.) MONDAY, APRIL 21, 2003 CERTIORARI -- SUMMARY DISPOSITION SAN PAOLO U. S. HOLDING V. SIMON, LIONEL The petition for a writ of certiorari is granted. The judgment is vacated and the case is remanded to the Court of Appeal of California, Second Appellate District, for further consideration in light of State Farm v. Campbell, 538 U.S. (2003) DeKALB GENETICS CORP. V. BAYER CropSCIENCE, S.A. The petition for a writ of certiorari is granted. The judgment is vacated and the case is remanded to the United States Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit for further consideration in light of State Farm v. Campbell, 538 U.S. (2003) KEY PHARMACEUTICALS, INC. V. EDWARDS, FREDERICK D. The petition for a writ of certiorari is granted. The judgment is vacated and the case is remanded to the Court of Appeals of Oregon for further consideration in light of State Farm v. Campbell, 538 U.S. (2003). Justice Breyer took no part in the consideration or decision of this case ANCHOR HOCKING, INC. V. WADDILL, ARLEEN E. The petition for a writ of certiorari is granted. The judgment is vacated and the case is remanded to the 1

2 Court of Appeals of Oregon for further consideration in light of State Farm v. Campbell, 538 U.S. (2003) NAT'L UNION FIRE INS. V. TEXTRON FINANCIAL CORP. The petition for a writ of certiorari is granted. The judgment is vacated and the case is remanded to the Court of Appeal of California, Fourth Appellate District, for further consideration in light of State Farm v. Campbell, 538 U.S. (2003) WOODFORD, WARDEN V. PAYTON, WILLIAM C. The motion of respondent for leave to proceed in forma pauperis is granted. The petition for a writ of certiorari is granted. The judgment is vacated and the case is remanded to the United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit for further consideration in light of Woodford v. Garceau, 538 U.S. (2003). ORDERS IN PENDING CASES 02M81 HUNTERSON, NEIL V. DiSABATO, MARY KEATING, ET AL. 02M82 HUTH, IRA V. YOUNG, ANTHONY L. 02M83 BARKER, DIANNE V. BAYLESS, BETSEY 02M85 CUNNINGHAM, JUDY V. LEWENSON, SANDRA, ET AL. 02M86 HOLT, ALFRED B. V. STATE ATTORNEY OFFICE The motions to direct the Clerk to file petitions for writs of certiorari out-of-time are denied. 02M84 EVANS, PERSONNA ANN V. ARKANSAS BOARD OF EDUCATION, ET AL. The motion to direct the Clerk to file a petition for a writ of certiorari out-of-time under Rule 14.5 is 2

3 denied. 02M88 REID, PAUL DENNIS V. TENNESSEE The motion for leave to proceed in forma pauperis without an affidavit of indigency executed by petitioner is denied PEABODY COAL CO. V. GROVES, WILMA J., ET AL. The motion of respondent Wilma J. Groves for attorney fees is denied without prejudice to filing in the United States Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit. Justice Scalia took no part in the consideration or decision of this motion FREW, LINDA, ETC., ET AL. V. HAWKINS, COMM'R, TX H&HS The motion of the parties to dispense with printing the joint appendix is granted GREEN FIRE INS. CO. V. M/V HYUNDAI LIBERTY NORFOLK SOUTHERN RWY. CO. V. JAMES N. KIRBY PTY, ET AL COOPER INDUSTRIES, INC. V. AVIALL SERVICES, INC. The Solicitor General is invited to file briefs in these cases expressing the views of the United States KAFELE, AJAMU M. V. KARNES, JIM, ET AL. The motion of petitioner for leave to proceed in forma pauperis is denied. Petitioner is allowed until May 12, 2003, within which to pay the docketing fee required by Rule 38(a) and to submit a petition in compliance with Rule 33.1 of the Rules of this Court. 3

4 CERTIORARI GRANTED ARIZONA V. GANT, RODNEY J UNITED STATES V. PATANE, SAMUEL F. The motions of respondents for leave to proceed in forma pauperis are granted. The petitions for writs of certiorari are granted GEN. DYNAMICS LAND SYS. V. CLINE, DENNIS, ET AL. The motion of Equal Employment Advisory Council, et al. for leave to file a brief as amici curiae is granted. The motion of Central States, Southeast and Southwest Areas Health and Welfare Fund for leave to file a brief as amicus curiae is granted. The petition for a writ of certiorari is granted SEC V. EDWARDS, CHARLES E. The motion of North American Securities Administrators Association, Inc. for leave to file a brief as amicus curiae is granted. The motion of Florida Department of Financial Services, et al. for leave to file a brief as amici curiae is granted. The motion of Public Investors Arbitration Bar Association, Inc. for leave to file a brief as amicus curiae is granted. The petition for a writ of certiorari is granted BANKS, DELMA V. COCKRELL, DIR., TX DCJ The motion of petitioner for leave to proceed in forma pauperis is granted. The petition for a writ of certiorari is granted limited to Questions 1, 2, and 3 presented by the petition. 4

5 CERTIORARI DENIED DeSTEFANO, NICHOLAS V. BROADWING COMMUNICATIONS KRILICH, ROBERT R., ET AL. V. UNITED STATES AirSTAR HELICOPTERS, INC. V. FAA, ET AL TIME WARNER ENTERTAINMENT V. SIX FLAGS OVER GEORGIA ) NILES, SERENA V. PARKINSON, GEOFFREY, ET AL. ) ) BONO, SALVATORE A. V. PARKINSON, GEOFFREY, ET AL STACEY, HELEN V. HERMITAGE, PA, ET AL ANDERSEN, DANIEL, ET AL. V. UNITED STATES, ET AL GAYLORD CONTAINER, ET AL. V. GARRETT PAPER INC., ET AL MICHIGAN V. JOHNSON, CEDRIC LEIDER, RICHARD V. UNITED STATES, ET AL ) SAN DIEGO, CA V. PAULSON, PHILIP K. ) ) MT. SOLEDAD MEM. ASSN., INC. V. PAULSON, PHILIP K., ET AL FLUELLEN, GEORGE V. BURGE, SUPT., AUBURN BAZARGANI, TAWOOS V. HAVERFORD ST. HOSP., ET AL GREGORY, GLENN G. V. TEXAS ZERLA, TERRANCE E. V. ERWIN, WARDEN JONES, WARDEN, ET AL. V. PACE, LEVI OATMAN, DONALD V. FUJI PHOTO FILM USA, INC CAMPBELL, DONALD G. V. FL DOC BRINES, KELLY, ET AL. V. XTRA CORP JOSEPH, ROBERT L. V. SALT LAKE CITY CIVIL SERVICE MAYES, ALFY L. V. GALVESTON JUVENILE DETENTION CHEN, JIANRONG V. NEW YORK, NY, ET AL CECG, INC. V. MAGIC SOFTWARE ENTERPRISES HARDAWAY, DERRICK V. YOUNG, WARDEN 5

6 RAISER, AARON V. UNITED STATES STEVENS, RICHARD V. NYAD, FIRST JUDICIAL DEPT REINHART, WILLIAM J. V. DEPT. OF AGRICULTURE BENES, FRANTISEK V. DALLAS, TX GALVAN, CIPRIANO, ET AL. V. DEPT. OF DEFENSE ILLINOIS V. SWIFT, AARON D HAYES, JOHN F. V. YORK, WARDEN RISTOVSKI, LJUPCO V. UNITED STATES BROWN, REBECCA, ETC. V. MUND, LOUIS I., ET AL CLARK, TREV V. LA MARQUE INDEP. SCH. DIST ROSENKRANTZ, ROBERT V. CALIFORNIA UNIFUND CCR PARTNERS, INC. V. MAGRIN, FRANK GRANT, HORACE V. FLORIDA EDWARDS, EDWIN B. V. RHODE ISLAND LOCKHEED INFORMATION MGMT. V. TOM STANLEY, ET AL MORENO, JOSE L. V. UNITED STATES O'CONNELL, DAVID D. V. METRO. GOVT. OF NASHVILLE ZIMMERMAN, DONALD, ET UX. V. CIR NISSENBAUM, ROBERT M. V. UNITED STATES MAYFIELD, RONALD J. V. MARYLAND EVANS, LEROY V. MSPB GIFFORD, SANDRA V. VAIL RESORTS, INC MATHIS, THELMA L. V. STAFFORD COUNTY, VA, ET AL CHAPMAN, RICHARD V. LeMASTER, WARDEN, ET AL PAYTON, WILLIAM C. V. WOODFORD, WARDEN GREEN, RONALD P. V. UNITED STATES PEREIRA, JOSEPH A. V. PLANT CITY, FL 6

7 WHITE, LEAMON V. ROPER, SUPT., POTOSI FRIEDMAN, GARY, ET AL. V. UNITED STATES RASMUSSEN, GARY V. UNITED STATES VEERAPOL, SUPAWAN V. UNITED STATES RINGER, ROBERT J. V. UNITED STATES KOLBERG, BRYAN V. MISSISSIPPI DELANCY, GEORGE C. V. FL DOC, ET AL BELL, VICTOR V. HERBERT, SUPT., ATTICA ESTES, ERNEST B. V. COCKRELL, DIR., TX DCJ SHERMAN, DARREN E. V. YARBOROUGH, WARDEN HADDAD, CONSTANCE E. V. MI NATIONAL CORP., ET AL HARRIS-PITTMAN, LEKESHIA V. NASH CTY. DEPT. OF SOC. SER LEE, KENNETH V. ENGLISH, THOMAS, ET AL SLATE, MARK E. V. WALKER, SUPT., AUBURN SILER, STANLEY R. V. VAVROSKY, DENNIS LOCKETT, CLAYTON D. V. OKLAHOMA LONGSTREET, ANDRE V. ILLINOIS McQUEEN, CURTIS V. SAGINAW COUNTY, MI MILLER, RANDY L. V. ALAMEIDA, DIR., CA DOC SWAFFORD, ROY C. V. FLORIDA MULLALLY, ROBERT T. V. LOS ANGELES, CA JOHNSON, ELTON E. V. NORRIS, DIR., AR DOC McCOWAN, HOWARD E. V. CALIFORNIA SMITH, KIP V. SMITH, STEPHANIE SMITH, DARNELL V. POLUNSKY, ALLEN, ET AL SLAUGHTER, MICHAEL L. V. COCKRELL, DIR., TX DCJ RANDY, MICHAEL J. V. STEPP, WARDEN 7

8 LUNDAHL, HOLLI V. ZIMMER, MARKUS B., ET AL MADDEN, ROGER C. V. BOBINSKI-CROAN, SUSAN LITMON, DAVID V. CALIFORNIA BROWN, ALTON D. V. RENDELL, GOV. OF PA, ET AL PHELPS, COY R. V. BEELER, WARDEN, ET AL ADANANDUS, ANTHONY V. KING CTY. PUB. DEFENSE ARVIE, HUBERT V. ANDRICH, RICHARD G., ET AL AHMED, NAWAZ V. HERSHEY, ADRIAN, ET AL BLONDHEIM, STEVEN H. V. OLMSTED COUNTY, MN, ET AL SCOTT, ALBERT L. V. OHIO RUSSELL, JOSEPH B. V. COCKRELL, DIR., TX DCJ SCARVER, CHRISTOPHER J. V. WISCONSIN TAYLOR, RUSSELL D. V. MILLER-STOUT, SUPT., AIRWAY VAUGHN, ANGELO V. MONEY, WARDEN YOUNG, ZURI S. V. ALAMEIDA, DIR., CA DOC HARRINGTON, MICHAEL V. DOWNS, JAMES, ET AL LIBERMAN, SHAY V. CITIBANK, N.A EATON, GERALD V. ILLINOIS HALL, EDWARD V. LENDIS, ZOI SHABTAI, DEVORAH V. GIULIANI, RUDOLPH, ET AL COOPER, KEVIN V. CALDERON, WARDEN, ET AL COBAS, NELSON V. BURGESS, MARY BRYANT, REGINALD M. V. GARCIA, WARDEN, ET AL STAMPS, IVAN C. V. DISTRICT COURT OF CO, ET AL TRAVERS, RICHARD A. V. CALIFORNIA YOUNG, JOSEPH V. ILLINOIS PENDLEY, FREDDIE L. V. COCKRELL, DIR., TX DCJ 8

9 MURPHY, PATRICK D. V. OKLAHOMA KIRSCH, MICHAEL C. V. COCKRELL, DIR., TX DCJ DANG, SANG X. V. COCKRELL, DIR., TX DCJ STEPHENSON, WILLIAM R. V. KRAMER, WARDEN, ET AL WELLS, LORRAINE A. V. CHU, LINDA J KENNER, JAMES E. V. LEWIS, WARDEN LaFAELE, TOVIA V. GARNICA, R KUTSKA, KEITH M. V. McCAUGHTRY, WARDEN PAYNE, RICHARD W. V. COCKRELL, DIR., TX DCJ CHAYOON, JOSEPH V. MASHANTUCKET PEQUOT GAMING ABDELSAMED, AHMED V. UNITED STATES LOVE, JAMES F. V. CARTER, WARDEN BROOKS, CALVIN B. V. HOOKS, WARDEN, ET AL SMITH, MILDRED V. OHIO BOWLING, CHARLES E. L. V. OHIO CROWELL, KELVIN V. MISSISSIPPI, ET AL DRAGER, HANK V. ILLINOIS DENSON, DAVID V. ILLINOIS VEGA, ELVER V. LOUISIANA DAVIS, JAMES V. FILION, SUPT., COXSACKIE CHILDRESS, RICARDO V. COCKRELL, DIR., TX DCJ GALLIEN, TRAVIS V. LOUISIANA AKHMAD, MUJAHID V. FARWELL, WARDEN, ET AL OXLEY, JOHN B. V. OREGON CORONEL, PAUL K. V. OKU, WILLIAM MORGAN, JONATHAN V. RAMIREZ, WARDEN PREVATTE, TED A. V. NORTH CAROLINA 9

10 LAWRENCE, JIMMIE W. V. NORTH CAROLINA JOLLEY, CHRISTY M. V. TEXAS JONES, ROSE G. V. OPM VOGEL, JOSHUA V. KEMNA, SUPT., CROSSROADS MOORE, TEDDY I. V. AMERICAN TRANSIT INS. CO PALMER, ROY L. V. DEPT. OF JUSTICE, ET AL BUNTING, PAUL E. V. OHIO ALLEN, VINCENT B. V. NORTH CAROLINA RUSTIN, ROBERT H. V. LaVIGNE, WARDEN DINGLE, BERNIE J. V. SOUTH CAROLINA SMITH, JERRY T. V. YARBOROUGH, WARDEN MITCHELL, GEORGE V. UNION PACIFIC RAILROAD LEE, BERNARD V. PENNSYLVANIA PROPER, JOHN P. V. WHITE, WARDEN ISAACS, CARL J. V. HEAD, WARDEN HARRISON, JEWEL V. LOCKYER, ATT'Y GEN. OF CA HARDING, TOD V. WALLS, WARDEN STURGEON, RONALD W. V. PIERSON, WARDEN RICHARDS, MARK E. V. JOHNSON, DIR., VA DOC MARTIN, JACQUAS L. V. USCA WADDELL, JOHN E. V. NORTH CAROLINA FAIRLEY, JESSE V. ILLINOIS RAMIREZ, MIGUEL A. V. McDANIEL, WARDEN, ET AL BLACK, CHRISTOPHER V. COCKRELL, DIR., TX DCJ BONDS, RICHARD V. PENNSYLVANIA BEY, MESSIAH A. V. WELSBACH ELEC. CORP., ET AL ROSENBACH, JAYME V. ILLINOIS 10

11 BISHOP, KEVIN V. HENDERSON, NV, ET AL WILLIAMS, HARRY V. VAUGHN, SUPT., GRATERFORD MONTOYA-LOPEZ, MIGUEL V. UNITED STATES HILL, EUGENE V. COWAN, WARDEN BAKER, ARCHIE D. V. WELLS, SHARON, ET AL BENTLEY, LISA D. V. DE DEPT. OF FAMILY SERV RIVERA-OROZCO, JORGE D. V. UNITED STATES PETERS, MONICA T. V. UNITED STATES SOTO-ORNELAS, MANUEL V. UNITED STATES RABAGO-VAZQUEZ, UBALDO V. UNITED STATES DIAZ, RAMON V. ILLINOIS FREDERICK, WINSTON V. UNITED STATES CASTILLO, RADAMES V. UNITED STATES CURRY, CARLOS V. UNITED STATES WINFIELD, REGINALD V. ILLINOIS WOODFIN, KENNETH W. V. JOHNSON, DIR., VA DOC McGHEE, TIMOTHY V. ILLINOIS ROMERO, ANDRES M. V. UNITED STATES HOLGUIN-PEREZ, ARMANDO V. UNITED STATES CORDERO, NICASIO V. UNITED STATES CARROLL, EDDIE V. UNITED STATES BANKS, DELMA V. COCKRELL, DIR., TX DCJ MILLER, MICHAEL M. V. UNITED STATES BONNER, RODERICK E. V. UNITED STATES LEVY, ALVERANG A. V. UNITED STATES LEVI, RICHARD V. UNITED STATES CARLISLE, CHRISTOPHER V. ILLINOIS 11

12 CARRILLO, GARY T. V. CALIFORNIA MONTALVO, MICHAEL L. V. CASTERLINE, WARDEN BRANNIC, LARRY V. USDC MD FL BUSH, CLINTON V. UNITED STATES RIVERA-ECHAVARRIA, JOSE S. V. UNITED STATES SOLIS-CAMPOZANO, JAIME V. UNITED STATES SWACKHAMMER, DONALD L. V. UNITED STATES LOTT, GARY A. V. UNITED STATES WOODS, MICHAEL T. V. UNITED STATES POWELL, AUSTIN L. V. UNITED STATES BELL, KARL B. V. UNITED STATES LAW, ROGER V. UNITED STATES RENGIFO, DONALDO V. UNITED STATES AKI, CHARMAINE V. UNITED STATES BUSTILLO-DELGADO, NELSON O. V. UNITED STATES LANE, DONALD V. UNITED STATES MENDEZ, ERIC V. UNITED STATES BRITO-BETANCOURT, TOMAS V. UNITED STATES GARCIA, DARBERTO V. UNITED STATES HOUSTON, O. C. V. HALL, SUPT., OLD COLONY GIVANS, RICHARD V. UNITED STATES SIMMONS, BRUCE V. UNITED STATES GREGORY, MICHAEL S. V. UNITED STATES GALLEGOS-DELGADO, REGINO V. UNITED STATES TUTTLE, CHRISTOPHER L. V. UNITED STATES ) WILLIAMS, MICHAEL W. V. UNITED STATES ) ) WILLIAMS, MELANTHIA V. UNITED STATES 12

13 MARTINEZ-CINTRON, JOSE V. UNITED STATES WATKINS, LEROY C., ET AL. V. UNITED STATES ESTRADA-TUFINO, JOSE L. V. UNITED STATES ASCHENBRENER, JOHN A. V. WISCONSIN PRATT, JAMES E. V. UNITED STATES PAREDES, NARGEL V. UNITED STATES ESPINOZA, JAVIER R. V. UNITED STATES BACH, DALE R. V. UNITED STATES JONES, NATHANIEL V. UNITED STATES BUTTS, LORENZO, ET AL. V. UNITED STATES CORTINAS, ENRIQUE V. UNITED STATES WARD, RONTHANY L. V. UNITED STATES DIEZ, JUAN M. V. UNITED STATES BOWE, BRYANT V. UNITED STATES, ET AL WILSON, REGINALD D. V. UNITED STATES WELLS, RODORRIO D. V. UNITED STATES JOHNSON, MELVIN V. UNITED STATES TILLITZ, ROBERT C. V. UNITED STATES VASQUEZ, JOSE E., ET AL. V. UNITED STATES DeCATO, RICHARD J. V. UNITED STATES DAWSON, RODERICK L. V. UNITED STATES RUSHIE, ROBERT V. UNITED STATES BRYANT, THOMAS V. UNITED STATES The petitions for writs of certiorari are denied McDANIEL, WARDEN, ET AL. V. VALERIO, JOHN E MICHIGAN V. HUTCHINSON, SHAWN D. The motions of respondents for leave to proceed in 13

14 forma pauperis are granted. The petitions for writs of certiorari are denied DUNCAN, DIANA V. GENERAL MOTORS CORPORATION The motion of NOW Legal Defense and Education Fund for leave to file a brief as amicus curiae is granted. The petition for a writ of certiorari is denied. HABEAS CORPUS DENIED IN RE KENNETH S. ONAPOLIS, ET UX IN RE KEVIN COOPER IN RE COY R. PHELPS IN RE JAMES ROBERT CALLAHAN The petitions for writs of habeas corpus are denied. MANDAMUS DENIED IN RE MICHAEL ANTHONY RODRIGUEZ IN RE WENDEL R. WARDELL, JR. The petitions for writs of mandamus are denied IN RE KEVIN SHAWN BLYDEN IN RE ROBERT S. SCRUGGS The petitions for writs of mandamus and/or prohibition are denied. REHEARINGS DENIED DANTAS, PAUL M. V. DOJ, ET AL PUCKETT, LARRY M. V. MISSISSIPPI NOTTI, EMIL, ET AL. V. COOK INLET REGION, INC. 14

15 ROLLESTON, MORETON V. SANDEASE, LTD., ET AL PERSIK, RAYMOND C. V. COLORADO MARTIN, JAMES L. V. WALMER, JOHN D., ET AL SCOTT, CORTEZ, T. V. ELO, WARDEN ROSS, BART A. V. ILLINOIS, ET AL PATTON, YVETTE V. LEMOINE, JOSEPH C., ET AL GOLDING, KENNETH B. V. UNITED STATES IN RE EILEEN VEY JOHONOSON, FRANKLIN V. SOBINA, SUPT., SOMERSET SHELTON, STANTON V. DOS SANTOS, ENRIQUE, ET AL JOHNSON, JOCELYN V. SMART & FINAL STORES CORP LAMBROS, JOHN G. V. UNITED STATES BOYD, BARRY A. V. BASKERVILLE, WARDEN NULL, THOMAS V. UNITED STATES TAYLOR, GLENN G. V. COCKRELL, DIR., TX DCJ BREEDLOVE, McARTHUR V. CROSBY, SEC., FL DOC WAGNER, MICHAEL L. V. CA DEPT. OF JUSTICE, ET AL JOHNSON, ELLOYD V. COCKRELL, DIR., TX DCJ KORNAFEL, STANLEY E. V. REPETTO, MAUREEN C WINTER, SYLVIA V. DEPT. OF AGRICULTURE IN RE JERRY LEE CUNNINGHAM CONKLE, CHRISTY D. V. POTTER, POSTMASTER GEN ODMAN, OWEN V. UNITED STATES BRYSON, LESTER D., ET AL. V. JOHNSTON, JUDGE, ETC DeLEON, FELIPE V. COCKRELL, DIR., TX DCJ LEWIS, SIDNEY T., ET AL. V. EMIGRANTS MORTGAGE COMPANY SCOTT, MARILYN V. ADULT PROTECTIVE SERVICES 15

16 HADDAD, CONSTANCE E. V. EEOC DEGLACE, CARLOS V. UNITED STATES BELLE, ANITA E. V. UNITED STATES, ET AL RIVERA, NEFTALI V. UNITED STATES The petitions for rehearing are denied EUBANKS-JACKSON, PATRICIA A. V. BANK OF AMERICA, N.A. The petition for rehearing is denied. Justice Breyer took no part in the consideration or decision of this petition WARD, RODERICK J. V. CROSBY, SEC., FL DOC, ET AL MORA, JULIO V. FLORIDA COBBLE, DANIEL V. KENTUCKY The motions for leave to file petitions for rehearing are denied. ATTORNEY DISCIPLINE D-2335 IN THE MATTER OF DISBARMENT OF MARK A. KOVLER Mark A. Kovler, of White Plains, New York, having been suspended from the practice of law in this Court by order of December 16, 2002; and a rule having been issued requiring him to show cause why he should not be disbarred; It is ordered that Mark A. Kovler is disbarred from the practice of law in this Court. 16

17 ORDER It is ordered that the call of the calendar, except for special assignments, be suspended for the Term upon conclusion of the cases listed for hearing on Wednesday, April 30,