Alexander Krivov, Sebastian Müller, Torsten Löhne, Harald Mutschke

Relaterede dokumenter
THE VEGA DEBRIS DISK: A SURPRISE FROM SPITZER

Remote Sensing til estimering af nedbør og fordampning

Generalized Probit Model in Design of Dose Finding Experiments. Yuehui Wu Valerii V. Fedorov RSU, GlaxoSmithKline, US

PARALLELIZATION OF ATTILA SIMULATOR WITH OPENMP MIGUEL ÁNGEL MARTÍNEZ DEL AMOR MINIPROJECT OF TDT24 NTNU

Introduction Ronny Bismark

Basic statistics for experimental medical researchers

The effects of occupant behaviour on energy consumption in buildings

Statistical information form the Danish EPC database - use for the building stock model in Denmark

Theoretical Wind Models

Translucent multiwall polycarbonate corrugated

A multimodel data assimilation framework for hydrology

UNISONIC TECHNOLOGIES CO.,

AFL10-LED-KIT Architectural FloodLight HID to LED Upgrade Kit kl_afl10_ledkit_spec.pdf

what is this all about? Introduction three-phase diode bridge rectifier input voltages input voltages, waveforms normalization of voltages voltages?

Brystkræftscreening og overdiagnostik hvordan forstår vi stigningen i incidens?

RAVE. The New Radar Motion Sensor Rated IP67: Optimized for Harsh Outdoor Applications

Energy-saving potential A case study of the Danish building stock. Kim B. Wittchen Danish Building Research Institute, SBi AALBORG UNIVERSITY

ETL Benchmarks. Version corrigée V 1.1. Comparing. DATASTAGE SERVER 7.5 DATASTAGE PX 7.5 TALEND OPEN STUDIO INFORMATICA 8.1.

Appendix 1 Properties of Fuels

Managing Muckpile Fragmentation Workshop. Scott G. Giltner

v Motivation v Multi- Atlas Segmentation v Learn Dictionary v Apply Dictionary v Results

Teknologispredning i sundhedsvæsenet DK ITEK: Sundhedsteknologi som grundlag for samarbejde og forretningsudvikling

Small Autonomous Devices in civil Engineering. Uses and requirements. By Peter H. Møller Rambøll

The MUSE Quasar-field Blind Emitter Surveys (MUSEQuBES)

Black Jack --- Review. Spring 2012

Svampegummi / Sponge rubber

Den uddannede har viden om: Den uddannede kan:

PEMS RDE Workshop. AVL M.O.V.E Integrative Mobile Vehicle Evaluation

Some recent improvements of the assimilation of upgraded ASAR L2 wave spectra

Vina Nguyen HSSP July 13, 2008

PROGRAM FOR ASTRONOMIDAGEN FREDAG, DEN 28. MARTS 2014

Studieordning del 3,

Application of High- resolution LiDAR-derived DEM in Landslide Volume Estimation

OG-3600 Series Fiber Optic Transport for opengear card frame platform w/ SNMP Management

Quantum Biochemistry. Jan H. Jensen Department of Chemistry University of Copenhagen. Slides can be found at: DOI: /m9.figshare.

Constant Terminal Voltage. Industry Workshop 1 st November 2013

APPENDIX E.3 SHADOW FLICKER CALCULATUIONS. 70 m TOWERS & 56 m BLADES

Particle-based T-Spline Level Set Evolution for 3D Object Reconstruction with Range and Volume Constraints

Central Statistical Agency.

Projekt DATA step view

VARIO D1. Samlet pris kr. XXXX,-

Komplet køreklar 6000 W Solcelle anlæg. Kr ,- inkl. moms

BADGES CATALOG d e s i g n p r o d u c e d e l i v e r

RADIANCE WORKSHOP, October ROHIT MANUDHANE CHRISTOPH REINHART Harvard Graduate School of Design

Komplet køreklar 3000 W Solcelle anlæg. Kr ,- inkl. moms

Sampling real algebraic varieties for topological data analysis

DGNB Bygherreforeningen. DGNB Juliane Münch Drees & Sommer Nordic Drees & Sommer

Slutrapport vedrørende Den Danske Maritime Fond, projekt no : Opdatering af emissionsbeslutningsstøttesystem.

Simulations of magnetoconvection and Solar-B. Max Planck Institute for Solar System Research

Terrain ETRS 89 Zone: 32 East North Name of wind Type Wind energy Mean wind speed Equivalent

I henhol til informationen givet i tryksagen Nationalt testcenter for vindmøller i Østerild Klitplantage fremsender undertegnede følgende forslag:

VLSI Design. DC & Transient Response. EE 447 VLSI Design 4: DC and Transient Response 1

Integrated Engine, Vehicle, and Underhood Model of a Light Duty Truck for VTM Analysis

X M Y. What is mediation? Mediation analysis an introduction. Definition

Dell P " 1440 x 900 VGA (HD-15) DisplayPort 60Hz Pivot Skærm VESA 100 x 100 mm

CISM COURSE COMPUTATIONAL ACOUSTICS

Generalforsamling 2013

Unitel EDI MT940 June Based on: SWIFT Standards - Category 9 MT940 Customer Statement Message (January 2004)

Using SL-RAT to Reduce SSOs

RPW This app is optimized for: For a full list of compatible phones please visit radiation. result.

Opera Ins. Model: MI5722 Product Name: Pure Sine Wave Inverter 1000W 12VDC/230 30A Solar Regulator

How consumers attributions of firm motives for engaging in CSR affects their willingness to pay

Rødsand laboratoriet et samarbejde mellem KU, Femern & DHI

Results of LArGe cryostat cooling tests

Selection of a Laser Source for Magnetic Field Imaging Using Magneto-optical Films

Healthcare Apps. OUH Odense University Hospital & Svendborg Hospital. Kiel, Germany, November /12/13

Gravitational structures!

Facilitering af Kreativitet & Innovation i VELUX Gruppen. Line Louise Overgaard Concepts & Innovation Support

Autodesk Simulation. Torben Christensen Niels Riis Christensen NTI CADCenter A/S

Kommune og Amts Revision Danmark Statsautoriseret Revisionsaktieselskab

Lovkrav vs. udvikling af sundhedsapps

Watch out ESG is here to stay! Eric Pedersen, Deputy CEO, Nordea Funds Ltd and CEO, Nordea Invest

Improved OVW Retrievals in Extreme High Wind Events using QuikSCAT

CHAPTER 8: USING OBJECTS

Remember the Ship, Additional Work

CS 4390/5387 SOFTWARE V&V LECTURE 5 BLACK-BOX TESTING - 2

Pattern formation Turing instability

DENCON ARBEJDSBORDE DENCON DESKS

Project Step 7. Behavioral modeling of a dual ported register set. 1/8/ L11 Project Step 5 Copyright Joanne DeGroat, ECE, OSU 1

Global carbon cycle studies with LPJ-GUESS

Maneurop reciprocating compressors

Heuristics for Improving

Managing stakeholders on major projects. - Learnings from Odense Letbane. Benthe Vestergård Communication director Odense Letbane P/S

PlanEnergi. Independent consultant Established in 1983 Specialised in:

talk outline sea bed network deployment issues; energy distribution seabed network issues;

Stier set med brugernes øjne. Planlægning af nye stier fakta, myter og muligheder. Hvem bruger stierne til hvad? Og hvad gør vi ved det?

Data Assimilation Models

Skriftlig eksamen Science statistik- ST501

Dynamic Voltage and Frequency Management Based on Variable Update Intervals

Præsentation af BETA II hæve/sænke bord

Shooting tethered med Canon EOS-D i Capture One Pro. Shooting tethered i Capture One Pro 6.4 & 7.0 på MAC OS-X & 10.8

H07RN-F CPR BESKRIVELSE STANDARDER. Kontakter Installation Tlf.: Support:

Design til digitale kommunikationsplatforme-f2013

1: Radialhastighedsmetoden I

KOMBINATION AF BIOGASPRODUKTION OG NATURPLEJE

USERTEC USER PRACTICES, TECHNOLOGIES AND RESIDENTIAL ENERGY CONSUMPTION

Håndtering af gods Transportører Let båndtransportør for pulvermaterialer

Neutron Activation of 76Ge

Integrated Coastal Zone Management and Europe

Projektledelse i praksis

Transkript:

From observations of debris dust to properties of planetesimals Alexander Krivov, Sebastian Müller, Torsten Löhne, Harald Mutschke Astrophysical Institute and University Observatory Friedrich Schiller University Jena Germany Planet Formation and Evolution: The Solar System and Extrasolar Planets Tübingen, March 3, 2009 1

A planetary system and its debris disk Planets Planetesimal belt + Debris dust = Debris disk Planet Formation and Evolution: The Solar System and Extrasolar Planets Tübingen, March 3, 2009 2

Outline Approach Application to unresolved disks Application to resolved disks Summary Planet Formation and Evolution: The Solar System and Extrasolar Planets Tübingen, March 3, 2009 3

Outline Approach Application to unresolved disks Application to resolved disks Summary Planet Formation and Evolution: The Solar System and Extrasolar Planets Tübingen, March 3, 2009 4

Idea of this work Traditional approach Planetesimal belt? Collisional model Our approach Dust disk Krivov, Müller, Löhne, & Mutschke, ApJ 687 (2008) Observables Planet Formation and Evolution: The Solar System and Extrasolar Planets Tübingen, March 3, 2009 5 Thermal emission model

Collisional model: ACE Initial planetesimal belt Analysis of Collisional Evolution Debris disk at subsequent time instants Features: - statistical code in an (m,a,e)-mesh - accurate photogravitational dynamics - collisions (mergers, cratering, disruption) - diffusion by P-R and stellar wind - distributed parallel computing Authors: Krivov & Sremčević (2003-2004), Löhne (2005-2009) Planet Formation and Evolution: The Solar System and Extrasolar Planets Tübingen, March 3, 2009 6

Results: dust distributions Distance-dependent size distribution Size-dependent radial distribution cf. Krivov, Löhne, & Sremčević, AAp 455 (2006) Thébault & Augereau, AAp 472 (2007) Löhne, PhD thesis (2008) Planet Formation and Evolution: The Solar System and Extrasolar Planets Tübingen, March 3, 2009 7

Thermal emission model: SEDUCE & SUBITO SED Utility for Circumstellar Environment Size and spatial distribution of dust, its optical properties SUrface Brightness Investigation TOol Features: - NextGen stellar photosphere models - Mie calculations for arbitrary (n,k) - Thermal emission (no scattered light) SED radial brightness profile Author: Müller (2007-2009) Planet Formation and Evolution: The Solar System and Extrasolar Planets Tübingen, March 3, 2009 8

Results: dust temperatures Absorption Efficiency Krivov, Müller, Löhne, & Mutschke, ApJ 687 (2008) Planet Formation and Evolution: The Solar System and Extrasolar Planets Tübingen, March 3, 2009 9

Outline Approach Application to unresolved disks Application to resolved disks Summary Planet Formation and Evolution: The Solar System and Extrasolar Planets Tübingen, March 3, 2009 10

Input and output Model parameters Star: stellar mass M * stellar luminosity L * stellar age t * Planetesimal belt: initial mass M 0 location r width dr excitation <e>,<i> known (fixed) poorly known (fixed) unknown (free) SED Observables All solids: Collisions: bulk density mechanical properties optical properties critical fragmentation energy fragments size distribution cratering efficiency Planet Formation and Evolution: The Solar System and Extrasolar Planets Tübingen, March 3, 2009 11

Reference disks 10EKBD @ 3AU 10EKBD @ 10AU 10EKBD @ 30AU 10EKBD @ 100AU 10EKBD @ 200AU G2V star Planet Formation and Evolution: The Solar System and Extrasolar Planets Tübingen, March 3, 2009 12

Scaling rules F (M 0, r, t) F (xm 0, r, t) = x F(M 0, r, xt) Löhne, Krivov, & Rodmann, ApJ 673 (2008) F (M 0, r, t) Planet Formation and Evolution: The Solar System and Extrasolar Planets Tübingen, March 3, 2009 13

Results: SEDs for reference disks Krivov, Müller, Löhne, & Mutschke, ApJ 687 (2008) Planet Formation and Evolution: The Solar System and Extrasolar Planets Tübingen, March 3, 2009 14

Application to selected debris disks Stars : G2V Dust data: from various surveys with IRAS, ISO, Spitzer, Keck II, JCMT Krivov, Müller, Löhne, & Mutschke, ApJ 687 (2008) Planet Formation and Evolution: The Solar System and Extrasolar Planets Tübingen, March 3, 2009 15

Comparison of observed SEDs to modeled SEDs F (M 0, r, t * ) Belt mass, from SED s height Krivov, Müller, Löhne, & Mutschke, ApJ 687 (2008) Belt location, from SED s peak wavelength Age, assumed known Planet Formation and Evolution: The Solar System and Extrasolar Planets Tübingen, March 3, 2009 16

Derived masses and locations of (outer) planetesimal belts System [HD] 377 70573 72905 107146 141943 ~130AU Belt mass [M earth ] 32 2.5 Ardila et al. ApJ 624, L141-142 (2005) 0.23 47 6.1 Belt location [AU] ~200 ~200 ~100 ~200 ~100 Dust mass [M earth ] 3.1x10-2 2.0x10-3 2.1x10-4 4.8x10-2 5.5x10-3 Large (100-200AU) and massive (0.2-50 earth masses) Kuiper belt analogs But: results sensitively depend on assumed dust properties Krivov, Müller, Löhne, & Mutschke, ApJ 687 (2008) Planet Formation and Evolution: The Solar System and Extrasolar Planets Tübingen, March 3, 2009 17

Outline Approach Application to unresolved disks Application to resolved disks Summary Planet Formation and Evolution: The Solar System and Extrasolar Planets Tübingen, March 3, 2009 18

Input and output Model parameters Star: stellar mass M * stellar luminosity L * stellar age t * Planetesimal belt: initial mass M 0 location r width dr excitation <e>,<i> All solids: bulk density mechanical properties optical properties known (fixed) poorly known (fixed) unknown (free) SED Observables Brightness profiles in different colors Collisions: critical fragmentation energy fragments size distribution cratering efficiency Planet Formation and Evolution: The Solar System and Extrasolar Planets Tübingen, March 3, 2009 19

Application to the Vega disk Su et al., ApJ (2005); Marsh et al., ApJ (2006) Planet Formation and Evolution: The Solar System and Extrasolar Planets Tübingen, March 3, 2009 20

The first-guess model Star: L * =37L sun Belt: 70-100AU, <e>=0.1 Material: astrosil Collisonal outcome model: nominal Müller, Löhne, & Krivov, in prep. Planet Formation and Evolution: The Solar System and Extrasolar Planets Tübingen, March 3, 2009 21

The best model Star: L * =25L sun Belt: 70-100AU, <e>=0.1 Material: astrosil Collisonal outcome model: flat size distribution of fragments Müller, Löhne, & Krivov, in prep. Planet Formation and Evolution: The Solar System and Extrasolar Planets Tübingen, March 3, 2009 22

Outline Approach Application to unresolved disks Application to resolved disks Summary Planet Formation and Evolution: The Solar System and Extrasolar Planets Tübingen, March 3, 2009 23

Summary We suggest a constructive way of using debris disk observations to constrain planetesimal properties Unresolved cases: application to five G2V excess stars revealed large (100-200AU) and massive (0.2-50 earth masses) Kuiper belt analogs Resolved cases: application to the Vega disk showed it to be compatible to a steady-state collisional evolution scenario, contrary to previous claims Herschel Open Time Key Program DUNES (DUst around NEarby Stars) Planet Formation and Evolution: The Solar System and Extrasolar Planets Tübingen, March 3, 2009 24