Cell Controller Pilot Project Intelligent Mobilization of Distributed Power Generation 1
Development from the late 1980s to present Primary Generation Local Generation Central power plant DCHP unit Wind turbine 2
Development of the Power Balance in Western Denmark 3
The Power System of Western Denmark Production Capacity per Voltage Level 400 kv 4 central CHP units (1488 MW) 150 kv 6 central CHP units (2014 MW) Horns Rev offshore wind farm (160 MW) 60 kv 17 dispersed CHP units (569 MW) 34 wind turbines (41 MW) 10-20 kv 475 dispersed CHP units (991 MW) 2180 wind turbines (1597 MW) 0,4 kv 260 dispersed CHP units (83 MW) 1860 wind turbines (576 MW) 4
Identified Targets of the Redesign Process Increased security of supply Sufficient domestic resources must be available to maintain a balance between demand and generation Improved operator knowledge of actual system conditions both locally and centrally Efficient system control particularly during emergencies Active usage of distributed passive generators Black starting capabilities using distributed generators Organising distributed generators into controllable Virtual Power Plants 5
150 kv Input Cell controller Output 60 kv 60 kv 60 kv 60 kv 10 kv 10 kv 10 kv 60 kv 60 kv 60 kv 10 kv 10 kv 60 kv 10 kv 6
Agent Level 4 (Dist. company B) Agent Level 5 (Energinet.dk) Agent Level 4 (Dist. company A) Cell Controller Architecture Layered control hierarchy using distributed agent technology and high speed fiber network Each agent consists either of an industry CPU, a high-end RTU or an intelligent meter Agent Level 3 (150/60 kv station) Agent Agent Agent Level 2 (60/10 kv stations) Agent Agent Agent Agent Level 1 (Assets) Agent Agent Agent Agent Agent Agent Level 0 (Units) ~ ~ ~ 7
Primary Design Criteria for the Cell Controller Pilot Project High Ambition: In case of an emergency situation reaching the point of no return the Cell disconnects itself from the HV grid and transfer to controlled island operation Moderate Ambition: After a total system collapse the Cell black-starts itself to a state of controlled island operation High Ambitions to ensure that new features can be implemented as pure software development without replacement or installation of new hardware 8
The Cell Controller Pilot Project Time Schedule Phase A 2004 Information gathering through 3 international workshops. Identification and selection of 60 kv Pilot Cell Area. Requirements spec and prelim design of Pilot Cell. 2005 B1 to B3 Implementation of measurement and monitoring system in Pilot Cell. Detailed modeling and simulation of Pilot Cell. Detailed design and laboratory-scale testing of Cell Controller in Colorado State University Diesel Engines Lab. 2009 C1 to C3 Pilot implementation and testing of Cell Controller in test area 1, 2 and 3 of Pilot Cell. 2011 9
Skodbjerge Hemmet Skjern Syd Tarm Tarm Vest Østergårde STOUSTRUP Ådum Knaplund Sdr Omme Barslund Skerris Give THYREGOD Kollemorten Hauge Honum Hadrup Lille Gedved Elbæk Ås Egebjerg HATTING Lund Blirup Bygholm Fussingvej Åboulevarden Drosselbo Horsens Kraftvarmeværk Sønderhov Torsvang Korning Ternevej Lerdrup Gosmer Nymindegab Filskov Krollerup Ølgod Uhe Farre Lindved Løsning Lindbjerg Årup Nr Nebel Lummerbæk Nollund Stilbjerg Grindsted Nord Bjerge Jelling Grejs Malle Hedensted Grindsted Grindsted Øst Lysholt Billund Mørup Ollerup Bredballe Henne Nr Marken Barrit Billund Nord Horne Sandegraven Tistrup Skelvangen Ørumgård Ansager KNABBERUP Outrup Billund Syd Vejle Elværk Sydkajen Vejle Ibæk Strandvej Krogager Hejnsvig Havn Ulvehaven Bindeballe Jerlev Vinding Karlsgårde Sdr Marken Gauerslund Nybro Nordenskov Rugstedlund Gårslev Oksbøl Varde Vorbasse Egtved Præstemarken Agerbæk Varde Øst RYTTERGÅRDEN Egeskovvej Alminde Sdr FAF Lindknud BredstrupvejTreldevej Årre Vilstrup Stovstrup Oksby Søbjerg LANDERUPGÅRD Børup Oldenborggade Glejbjerg Bække Sandal Jegsmark Erritsø Endrup Lilballe Taulov Tobøl Vr Nebel BRAMDRUP Snoghøj Brøndumdam Edelsborg Gejsing Højrup SVS Sædding Gjesing Surhave Hedelund Harte Brogård Vibevej Bramminge Holsted Holsted Syd Svineryggen Nygårdsvej Tjæreborg Gørding Vejen Vest Brørup ANDST Ålegård Estrupvej Vejen Nagbøl Vonsild Bramminge Øst Askov Føvling Sdr Bjert Rindby Lykkegård Vamdrup Skodborg Skudstrup Kongeå Åstorp Gredstedbro Glud Juelsminde Syd Energi Net A/S Rømø Hjortvad Rødding Nord Ribe Nord Brøstrup Christiansfeld Ribe Centrum Ribe Rødding Syd Sønder Hygum Gram Hviding Nustrup Jegerup Vojens Øst Spandet Vojens Nord Vojens Vest Brøns Frifelt Tislund Bevtoft Over Jerstal Åved Toftlund Skærbæk Øst Hyrup Skærbæk Syd Nr Løgum Agerskov Jels Revsø Fjelstrup Sommersted Thomashus Magstrup Tyrstrup Haderslev Vest Hammelev Åstrupbro Øsby Haderslev Øst Vandling Langkær Hejsager Hoptrup Løjt Ballum Rejsby Hede Visby Bredebro Løgumkloster Hellevad Mårbæk Kassø Abild Bredevad Lendemark Højer Rosinfelt Tved Tønder Nord Lund Tønder Vest Jejsing Tønder Øst Rens RødekroBrunde Vest Rise-Hjarup Åbenrå Nord Rødekro Øst Vennelyst Søst Åbenrå Vest Åbenråværket Åbenrå Syd Hjordkær Bolderslev Enstedværket Varnæs Lundsbjerg Felsted 6 0 kv Hardeshøj Blåkrog Ballebro Blans Nordborg Avnbøl Tinglev Nord Kliplev Kværs QSØ Augustenborg Bro Vester Sottrup Tinglev Syd Alnor Ragebøl Egernsund Broager Nord Bajstrup Gråsten Øster Gejl Kastanie Allé Rojumvej Broager Syd Mjels Havnbjerg Danfoss Lunden Stevning Guderup Asserballe Mjang Sønderborg Tandslet Sarup Bov Kruså Frøslev Padborg Uw-Nord Stadtwerke Kort & matrikelstyrelsen (G. 17-01) Copyright 10
Pilot Cell: SS Holsted 60 kv Grid Area Test Area 1 8,8 MW G BID MØR Installed CHP: 37 MW Installed Wind: 39 MW Max Load: 61 MW 150/60 kv Trafo: 100 MVA 2 MW G HEJ Wind BIO 4 MW BIS Wind 7 MW ÅRR AGB 3,3 MW Wind VOB LIK Test Area 3 G 15,5 MW 2 MW BMØ Wind GØR GLE HOS FØV 2 MW HOD Wind G 3 MW 3,8 MW G BRØ Wind 2 MW VJV REV Wind Test Area 2 3,6 MW 11
Deliverables and Features Deliverables: Features: Cell Monitoring System Upgrading Assets Shock Absorbers Cell Controller Modeling and Simulation Testing in a Grid Simulation Laboratory Testing Live On-line field data collection for analysis purposes and for input to the CC CC enabling of assets in the test area Synchronous Condenser and Secondary Load Controller On-line System Control e.g. islanding and black starting capability Simulation and verification of CC functionalities in a safe computer model environment Verification of CC functionalities in a safe laboratory environment Verification of CC functionalities in a real 60/10 kv distribution grid 12
Progress Deliverables: Area 1 Area 2 Area 3 Cell Monitoring System Planned for 2009 Upgrading Assets Planned for 2009 Planned for 2010 Shock Absorbers Planned for 2009 Planned for 2010 Cell Controller Proto type developed Planned for 2009 Planned for 2010 Modeling and Simulation In progress In progress Planned for 2010 Testing in a Grid Simulation Laboratory In progress Planned for 2009 Planned for 2010 Testing Live Planned for Q4 2008 Planned for 2010 Planned for 2011 13
Lifting Shock Absorbers in place at Hejnsvig 60/10 kv substation 800 kva Synchronous Condenser (SC) for voltage control 1000 kw Secondary Load Controller (SLC) for frequency control each in a 40 feet container complete with control and protection equipment and 10 kv grid connection 14
CMS Installation at Hejnsvig and Billund CHP units 15
CMS Installation at Trøllund Wind Turbines 16
CMS screen for Hejnsvig 60/10 kv substation 17
CMS Data Analysis Area 1 Wind Gust 1: Wind Moving Down Line Total Ramp: 3060 KW in 77s Max Gradient: 1800 KW in 18s 4500 4000 Power (KW) 3500 3000 2500 2000 1500 1000 20 Seconds WT1 WT2 WT3 WT4 Trollund 500 0 10-07 12:28:48.0 10-07 12:29:31.2 10-07 12:30:14.4 10-07 12:30:57.6 10-07 12:31:40.8 10-07 12:32:24.0 Time Wind Gust 4: Perpendicular Gust Total Ram p:1750 KW in 32 s Max Gradient: 78 KW/s 4500 4000 3500 WT1 Power (KW) 3000 2500 2000 1500 WT2 WT3 WT4 Sum WTG 1000 500 Trollund 0 11-09 13:24:57.6 11-09 13:25:40.8 11-09 13:26:24.0 11-09 13:27:07.2 11-09 13:27:50.4 11-09 13:28:33.6 11-09 13:29:16.8 Time 18
Grid Simulation Laboratory (GSL) Colorado State University Engines and Energy Conversion Laboratory Fort Collins, Colorado, USA 19
GSL one-line diagram 13,2 KV Bus 1 Existing Service 750 KVA 480/277 Volt Bus 50 51 50N 51N 32 67 Multifunction Relay Bus 2 1600 A Bus 480/277 Volt Bus 1200 1600 25 480/277 Volts 208/120 Volts 3 PT s 480/120 (Typical) 2000:5 150 200:5 25 Gen Prot 150 25 150 25 400 25 600 25 150 25 1600 25 200:5 Gen Prot 200:5 Gen Prot 400:5 Gen Prot 600:5 200:5 3000:5 Gen Prot EECL Loads Load Bank Load Bank 125 KW Wind Turbine Simulator (Induction Gen) Gen 2 85 KW Gen 3 85 KW Synchronous Condenser 125 KVAR Utility Load Sim 400 KW 0.8 PF Secondary Load Controller 100 KW Gen 1 1600 KW (Planned) 20
Cell Controller Concept Expectations Each Cell can be regarded as a Virtual Generator with same or better controllability compared to a traditional power station unit of equal size Local distribution companies attain strongly increased possibilities of active distribution network on-line monitoring and control Automatic Cell transition to controlled island operation in case of imminent transmission system break-down Black-start of transmission system Robust Cell Controller Concept designed to encompass all new types of DG units and controller functionalities Increase in security of supply Any new functionality as pure software development Re-design for the future Danish electric power system 21
Per Lund Head of System Development Phone : +45 7622 4423 Mobile : +45 2333 8609 plu@energinet.dk Energinet.dk Tonne Kjærsvej 65 7000 Fredericia 22