Til Karsten Kolle. Jeg sender dette til dig, som Ann Danielsen fra Siemens har udarbejdet. Venlig hilsen Michael Antonisen Tårsvej 53 4990 Sakskøbing 54772047-29475452 From: Danielsen, Ann (E W EMEA ON S1 1) Sent: Wednesday, May 23, 2012 1:41 PM To: dahl-antonisen@mail.dk Cc: Jensen, Carl (E W EMEA ON S1) Subject: L1 Hej Michael, Vedhæftet er et placeringsforslag L1: 3 stk. SWT-3.0-113_83,5NH. Jeg har lavet forslaget med en totalhøjde på 140m, så at der kan være mere plads imellem møllerne. Beregningen forudsætter at de 8 eksisterende Vestas møller nedtages. WINDWORLD møllen er heller ikke medberegnet, hvis den skal blive stående, ville de nye møller skulle støjreduceres yderligere for at overholde støj ved Arildseje. For at lave en finjustering af placeringen skal vi have landmålerkoordinater for naboerne og afklaret hvilke naboer er ejere af WINDWORLD møllen og hvor stor andel de ejer, da de så ville kunne ses bort fra støj ved disse naboer. De ville også være muligt at placere en fjerde mølle syd for rækken, med jeg var usikker på, hvor stort området kommunen har udlagt, er det begrænset af afstand til naboer eller andre faktorer. Nedenfor er kort med markerede fredede områder og 563m afstand fra naboer. Du er velkommen at kontakte mig hvis du har nogen spørgsmål Med Venlig Hilsen, Ann Danielsen E W EMEA ON S1 1 Finsensvej 1 7430 Ikast, Denmark Mobile: +45 3037-5181 mailto:ann.danielsen@siemens.com http://www.siemens.com/wind
DECIBEL - Main Result Noise calculation model: Danish 2011 The calculation is based on the "Bekendtgørelse nr. 1284 af 15. december 2011" from the Danish Environmental Agency. The noise impact from WTGs are not allowed to exceed the following limits: (Wind speeds in 10 m height) 1) At outdoor areas maximum 15 m from neighbor settlements in the open land. a) 44 db(a) at wind speed 8 m/s. b) 42 db(a) at wind speed 6 m/s. 2) At outdoor areas in residential or recreational areas. a) 39 db(a) at wind speed 8 m/s in residential areas. b) 37 db(a) at wind speed 6 m/s in residential areas. The low frequency noise impact from WTGs are not allowed to exceed 20 db indoor at wind speeds 8 and 6 m/s The limits are not to be taken into acount for houses belonging to WTG owner 5/23/2012 1:19 PM / 1 WTGs New WTG Scale 1:100,000 Noise sensitive area UTM (north)-etrs89 Zone: 32 WTG type Noise data East North Z Row data/description Valid Manufact. Type-generator Power, Rotor Hub Creator Name First LwaRef Last LwaRef Pure rated diameter height wind wind tones speed speed UTM (north)-etrs89 Zone: 32 [m] [kw] [m] [m] [m/s] [db(a)] [m/s] [db(a)] 1 669,800 6,080,587 0.0 Siemens SWT-3.0-113, DD 3000... Yes Siemens SWT-3.0-113, DD-3,000 3,000 113.0 83.5 USER Standad setting NH83,5 6.0 104.5 8.0 106.0 No 2 669,977 6,080,990 0.0 Siemens SWT-3.0-113, DD 3000... Yes Siemens SWT-3.0-113, DD-3,000 3,000 113.0 83.5 USER Standad setting NH83,5 6.0 104.5 8.0 106.0 No 3 670,154 6,081,393 0.0 Siemens SWT-3.0-113, DD 3000... Yes Siemens SWT-3.0-113, DD-3,000 3,000 113.0 83.5 USER Standart setting -2 db NH83,5 6.0 103.4 8.0 104.0 No Calculation Results Sound Level Noise sensitive area UTM (north)-etrs89 Zone: 32 Demands Sound Level Demands fulfilled? No. Name East North Z Imission Wind Noise Distance From WTGs Noise Distance All height speed [m] [m] [m/s] [db(a)] [m] [db(a)] A Noise sensitive point: Danish 2007 - Open land (1) 670,532 6,081,826 0.0 1.5 6.0 42.0 563 38.6 Yes Yes Yes A 8.0 44.0 39.2 Yes Yes B Noise sensitive point: Danish 2007 - Open land (2) 670,682 6,081,831 0.0 1.5 6.0 42.0 563 37.2 Yes Yes Yes B 8.0 44.0 37.8 Yes Yes C Noise sensitive point: Danish 2007 - Open land (3) 670,767 6,081,758 0.0 1.5 6.0 42.0 563 36.9 Yes Yes Yes C 8.0 44.0 37.5 Yes Yes D Noise sensitive point: Danish 2007 - Open land (4) 670,842 6,081,673 0.0 1.5 6.0 42.0 563 36.7 Yes Yes Yes D 8.0 44.0 37.3 Yes Yes E Noise sensitive point: Danish 2007 - Open land (5) 670,924 6,081,628 0.0 1.5 6.0 42.0 563 36.1 Yes Yes Yes E 8.0 44.0 36.7 Yes Yes F Noise sensitive point: Danish 2007 - Open land (6) 670,922 6,081,453 0.0 1.5 6.0 42.0 563 36.7 Yes Yes Yes F 8.0 44.0 37.4 Yes Yes G Noise sensitive point: Danish 2007 - Open land (7) 670,974 6,081,368 0.0 1.5 6.0 42.0 563 36.4 Yes Yes Yes G 8.0 44.0 37.1 Yes Yes H Noise sensitive point: Danish 2007 - Residential areas (8) 670,997 6,081,243 0.0 1.5 6.0 37.0 563 36.3 Yes Yes Yes H 8.0 39.0 37.0 Yes Yes I Noise sensitive point: Danish 2007 - Residential areas (9) 670,979 6,081,221 0.0 1.5 6.0 37.0 563 36.5 Yes Yes Yes I 8.0 39.0 37.2 Yes Yes J Noise sensitive point: Danish 2007 - Residential areas (10) 670,967 6,081,198 0.0 1.5 6.0 37.0 563 36.6 Yes Yes Yes J 8.0 39.0 37.3 Yes Yes K Noise sensitive point: Danish 2007 - Open land (11) 670,844 6,081,043 0.0 1.5 6.0 42.0 563 37.9 Yes Yes Yes K 8.0 44.0 38.7 Yes Yes L Noise sensitive point: Danish 2007 - Open land (12) 670,744 6,080,908 0.0 1.5 6.0 42.0 563 38.8 Yes Yes Yes L 8.0 44.0 39.6 Yes Yes M Noise sensitive point: Danish 2007 - Open land (13) 670,727 6,080,888 0.0 1.5 6.0 42.0 563 38.9 Yes Yes Yes M 8.0 44.0 39.8 Yes Yes N Noise sensitive point: Danish 2007 - Open land (14) 670,717 6,080,863 0.0 1.5 6.0 42.0 563 38.9 Yes Yes Yes N 8.0 44.0 39.8 Yes Yes O Noise sensitive point: Danish 2007 - Open land (15) 670,572 6,080,678 0.0 1.5 6.0 42.0 563 39.9 Yes Yes Yes O 8.0 44.0 40.9 Yes Yes P Noise sensitive point: Danish 2007 - Open land (16) 670,514 6,080,541 0.0 1.5 6.0 42.0 563 39.8 Yes Yes Yes P 8.0 44.0 40.8 Yes Yes Q Noise sensitive point: Danish 2007 - Open land (17) 670,454 6,080,441 0.0 1.5 6.0 42.0 563 39.8 Yes Yes Yes Q 8.0 44.0 40.8 Yes Yes To be continued on next page...
DECIBEL - Main Result 5/23/2012 1:19 PM / 2...continued from previous page Noise sensitive area UTM (north)-etrs89 Zone: 32 Demands Sound Level Demands fulfilled? No. Name East North Z Imission Wind Noise Distance From WTGs Noise Distance All height speed [m] [m] [m/s] [db(a)] [m] [db(a)] R Noise sensitive point: Danish 2007 - Open land (18) 670,387 6,080,416 0.0 1.5 6.0 42.0 563 40.4 Yes Yes Yes R 8.0 44.0 41.4 Yes Yes S Noise sensitive point: Danish 2007 - Open land (19) 670,354 6,080,371 0.0 1.5 6.0 42.0 563 40.4 Yes Yes Yes S 8.0 44.0 41.4 Yes Yes T Noise sensitive point: Danish 2007 - Open land (20) 670,277 6,080,266 0.0 1.5 6.0 42.0 563 40.2 Yes Yes Yes T 8.0 44.0 41.3 Yes Yes U Noise sensitive point: Danish 2007 - Open land (21) 670,247 6,080,236 0.0 1.5 6.0 42.0 563 40.2 Yes Yes Yes U 8.0 44.0 41.3 Yes Yes V Noise sensitive point: Danish 2007 - Open land (25) 670,224 6,080,208 0.0 1.5 6.0 42.0 563 40.1 Yes Yes Yes V 8.0 44.0 41.2 Yes Yes W Noise sensitive point: Danish 2007 - Open land (26) 670,189 6,080,148 0.0 1.5 6.0 42.0 563 39.7 Yes Yes Yes W 8.0 44.0 40.8 Yes Yes X Noise sensitive point: Danish 2007 - Open land (27) 670,139 6,080,083 0.0 1.5 6.0 42.0 563 39.3 Yes Yes Yes X 8.0 44.0 40.3 Yes Yes Y Noise sensitive point: Danish 2007 - Open land (28) 670,079 6,080,003 0.0 1.5 6.0 42.0 563 38.6 Yes Yes Yes Y 8.0 44.0 39.7 Yes Yes Z Noise sensitive point: Danish 2007 - Open land (29) 670,012 6,079,918 0.0 1.5 6.0 42.0 563 37.8 Yes Yes Yes Z 8.0 44.0 38.8 Yes Yes AA Noise sensitive point: Danish 2007 - Open land (30) 669,979 6,079,823 0.0 1.5 6.0 42.0 563 36.7 Yes Yes Yes AA 8.0 44.0 37.8 Yes Yes AB Noise sensitive point: Danish 2007 - Open land (31) 669,979 6,079,823 0.0 1.5 6.0 42.0 563 36.7 Yes Yes Yes AB 8.0 44.0 37.8 Yes Yes AC Noise sensitive point: Danish 2007 - Open land (32) 669,917 6,079,756 0.0 1.5 6.0 42.0 563 36.0 Yes Yes Yes AC 8.0 44.0 37.1 Yes Yes AD Noise sensitive point: Danish 2007 - Open land (33) 669,824 6,079,631 0.0 1.5 6.0 42.0 563 34.7 Yes Yes Yes AD 8.0 44.0 35.8 Yes Yes AE Noise sensitive point: Danish 2007 - Open land (34) 669,794 6,079,526 0.0 1.5 6.0 42.0 563 33.7 Yes Yes Yes AE 8.0 44.0 34.7 Yes Yes AF Noise sensitive point: Danish 2007 - Open land (35) 669,749 6,079,421 0.0 1.5 6.0 42.0 563 32.8 Yes Yes Yes AF 8.0 44.0 33.8 Yes Yes AG Noise sensitive point: Danish 2007 - Open land (36) 669,749 6,079,421 0.0 1.5 6.0 42.0 563 32.8 Yes Yes Yes AG 8.0 44.0 33.8 Yes Yes AH Noise sensitive area: Danish 2007 - Open land (37) 669,732 6,079,393 0.0 1.5 6.0 42.0 563 32.5 Yes Yes Yes AH 8.0 44.0 33.5 Yes Yes AI Noise sensitive point: Danish 2007 - Open land (38) 669,722 6,079,378 0.0 1.5 6.0 42.0 563 32.4 Yes Yes Yes AI 8.0 44.0 33.4 Yes Yes AJ Noise sensitive point: Danish 2007 - Open land (39) 669,674 6,079,328 0.0 1.5 6.0 42.0 563 31.9 Yes Yes Yes AJ 8.0 44.0 33.0 Yes Yes AK Noise sensitive point: Danish 2007 - Open land (40) 669,527 6,079,281 0.0 1.5 6.0 42.0 563 31.4 Yes Yes Yes AK 8.0 44.0 32.4 Yes Yes AL Noise sensitive point: Danish 2007 - Open land (41) 669,397 6,079,301 0.0 1.5 6.0 42.0 563 31.3 Yes Yes Yes AL 8.0 44.0 32.3 Yes Yes AM Noise sensitive point: Danish 2007 - Open land (42) 669,307 6,079,361 0.0 1.5 6.0 42.0 563 31.5 Yes Yes Yes AM 8.0 44.0 32.5 Yes Yes AN Noise sensitive point: Danish 2007 - Open land (43) 669,197 6,079,486 0.0 1.5 6.0 42.0 563 32.0 Yes Yes Yes AN 8.0 44.0 33.0 Yes Yes AO Noise sensitive point: Danish 2007 - Open land (44) 669,012 6,079,663 0.0 1.5 6.0 42.0 563 32.4 Yes Yes Yes AO 8.0 44.0 33.4 Yes Yes AP Noise sensitive point: Danish 2007 - Open land (45) 668,924 6,079,718 0.0 1.5 6.0 42.0 563 32.2 Yes Yes Yes AP 8.0 44.0 33.2 Yes Yes AQ Noise sensitive point: Danish 2007 - Open land (46) 668,864 6,079,738 0.0 1.5 6.0 42.0 563 32.0 Yes Yes Yes AQ 8.0 44.0 33.0 Yes Yes AR Noise sensitive point: Danish 2007 - Open land (47) 668,842 6,079,838 0.0 1.5 6.0 42.0 563 32.4 Yes Yes Yes AR 8.0 44.0 33.4 Yes Yes AS Noise sensitive point: Danish 2007 - Open land (48) 668,844 6,079,913 0.0 1.5 6.0 42.0 563 32.8 Yes Yes Yes AS 8.0 44.0 33.8 Yes Yes AT Noise sensitive point: Danish 2007 - Open land (49) 668,844 6,079,913 0.0 1.5 6.0 42.0 563 32.8 Yes Yes Yes AT 8.0 44.0 33.8 Yes Yes AU Noise sensitive point: Danish 2007 - Open land (50) 668,904 6,079,956 0.0 1.5 6.0 42.0 563 33.5 Yes Yes Yes AU 8.0 44.0 34.5 Yes Yes AV Noise sensitive point: Danish 2007 - Open land (51) 668,902 6,080,008 0.0 1.5 6.0 42.0 563 33.7 Yes Yes Yes AV 8.0 44.0 34.8 Yes Yes AW Noise sensitive point: Danish 2007 - Open land (52) 668,902 6,080,068 0.0 1.5 6.0 42.0 563 34.1 Yes Yes Yes AW 8.0 44.0 35.1 Yes Yes AX Noise sensitive point: Danish 2007 - Open land (53) 669,062 6,080,646 0.0 1.5 6.0 42.0 563 37.8 Yes Yes Yes AX 8.0 44.0 38.8 Yes Yes AY Noise sensitive point: Danish 2007 - Open land (54) 669,244 6,080,811 0.0 1.5 6.0 42.0 563 40.2 Yes Yes Yes AY 8.0 44.0 41.2 Yes Yes AZ Noise sensitive point: Danish 2007 - Open land (55) 669,147 6,080,891 0.0 1.5 6.0 42.0 563 38.7 Yes Yes Yes AZ 8.0 44.0 39.8 Yes Yes BA Noise sensitive point: Danish 2007 - Open land (56) 669,147 6,081,003 0.0 1.5 6.0 42.0 563 38.5 Yes Yes Yes BA 8.0 44.0 39.5 Yes Yes To be continued on next page...
DECIBEL - Main Result 5/23/2012 1:19 PM / 3...continued from previous page Noise sensitive area UTM (north)-etrs89 Zone: 32 Demands Sound Level Demands fulfilled? No. Name East North Z Imission Wind Noise Distance From WTGs Noise Distance All height speed [m] [m] [m/s] [db(a)] [m] [db(a)] BB Noise sensitive point: Danish 2007 - Open land (57) 669,152 6,081,043 0.0 1.5 6.0 42.0 563 38.4 Yes Yes Yes BB 8.0 44.0 39.4 Yes Yes BC Noise sensitive point: Danish 2007 - Open land (58) 669,177 6,081,091 0.0 1.5 6.0 42.0 563 38.5 Yes Yes Yes BC 8.0 44.0 39.5 Yes Yes BD Noise sensitive point: Danish 2007 - Open land (59) 669,392 6,081,131 0.0 1.5 6.0 42.0 563 40.9 Yes Yes Yes BD 8.0 44.0 41.9 Yes Yes BE Noise sensitive point: Danish 2007 - Open land (60) 669,264 6,081,313 0.0 1.5 6.0 42.0 563 38.5 Yes Yes Yes BE 8.0 44.0 39.4 Yes Yes BF Noise sensitive point: Danish 2007 - Open land (61) 669,317 6,081,566 0.0 1.5 6.0 42.0 563 37.6 Yes Yes Yes BF 8.0 44.0 38.4 Yes Yes Distances (m) WTG NSA 1 2 3 A 1439 1003 575 B 1525 1097 686 C 1519 1102 713 D 1505 1102 743 E 1532 1142 805 F 1417 1052 770 G 1410 1067 821 H 1365 1051 856 I 1339 1028 843 J 1317 1011 836 K 1139 869 774 L 997 772 764 M 974 757 763 N 957 750 773 O 777 671 828 P 716 700 925 Q 670 727 998 R 611 705 1004 S 595 725 1041 T 575 784 1134 U 568 801 1161 V 569 820 1187 W 586 868 1245 X 607 921 1310 Y 647 992 1391 Z 701 1072 1481 AA 784 1167 1579 AB 784 1167 1579 AC 839 1236 1654 AD 957 1368 1793 AE 1061 1475 1901 AF 1167 1586 2013 AG 1167 1586 2013 AH 1196 1615 2044 AI 1211 1632 2060 AJ 1265 1689 2119 AK 1335 1767 2203 AL 1348 1786 2225 AM 1322 1762 2202 AN 1256 1694 2134 AO 1214 1641 2073 AP 1234 1651 2078 AQ 1263 1675 2098 AR 1216 1617 2034 AS 1169 1563 1976 AT 1169 1563 1976 AU 1096 1490 1904 To be continued on next page...
DECIBEL - Main Result...continued from previous page WTG NSA 1 2 3 AV 1069 1456 1867 AW 1037 1416 1823 AX 741 978 1323 AY 599 754 1080 AZ 721 836 1125 BA 775 830 1080 BB 793 827 1061 BC 801 807 1023 BD 680 602 806 BE 903 783 893 BF 1092 876 855 5/23/2012 1:19 PM / 4
DECIBEL - Map 6.0 m/s 5/23/2012 1:19 PM / 5 Noise [db(a)] 37 42 0 250 500 750 1000 m Map: Kort25-0505_6100_660 6100_660, Print scale 1:25,000, Map center UTM (north)-etrs89 Zone: 32 East: 669,977 North: 6,080,990 New WTG Noise sensitive area Noise calculation model: Danish 2011. Wind speed: 6.0 m/s Height above sea level: 0.0 m
DECIBEL - Map 8.0 m/s 5/23/2012 1:19 PM / 6 Noise [db(a)] 39 44 0 250 500 750 1000 m Map: Kort25-0505_6100_660 6100_660, Print scale 1:25,000, Map center UTM (north)-etrs89 Zone: 32 East: 669,977 North: 6,080,990 New WTG Noise sensitive area Noise calculation model: Danish 2011. Wind speed: 8.0 m/s Height above sea level: 0.0 m