Københavns Universitet. Danske aktiekurser og basale kapitalværdier Mossin, Axel. Publication date: Document Version Også kaldet Forlagets PDF

Transkript

1 university of copenhagen Københavns Universitet Danske aktiekurser og basale kapitalværdier Mossin, Axel Publication date: 23 Document Version Også kaldet Forlagets PDF Citation for published version (APA): Mossin, A. (23). Danske aktiekurser og basale kapitalværdier. Kbh.: Museum Tusculanum. Download date: 25. May. 219

2 Blå Memoserie Økonomisk Institut Københavns Universitet Nr. 29 maj 23 Danske aktiekurser og basale kapitalværdier Axel Mossin Studiestræde 6, 1455 København K Tel Fax ISSN: (print) ISSN: X (online)

3 'DQVNHDNWLHNXUVHURJEDVDOHNDSLWDOY UGLHU DI$[HORVVLQ NRQRPLVN,QVWLWXW. EHQKDYQV8QLYHUVLWHW $NWLHUQHVRSWXUHRJQHGWXUH,O EHWDIHUQHVWHJDNWLHNXUVHUQHVW UNW'HGDQVNHDNWLHNXUVHUQnHGHK MGH SXPNWHULRNWREHURJLMDQXDUIRUVLGHQDWPLVWHHQPHJHWY VHQWOLJGHO DIGHQYXQGQHY UGL'LDJUDPYLVHUNXUVXGYLNOLQJHQIUDMDQXDUWLODSULO 8OWLPRYDUPDUNHGVY UGLHQDIDNWLHUQRWHUHWSn. EHQKDYQV)RQGVE UV PLOOLDUGHUNURQHUNLOGH)RQGVE UVHQV)D W%RRN)UDXOWLPRWLOXOWLPR IDOGWDNWLHLQGHNVHWPHG D)RUPXHWDEHWRYHUGHQQHSHULRGHHUVnOHGHV RSPRGDIPLOOLDUGHUNURQHUGYVRSPRGPLOOLDUGHUNURQHU'D QRJOHVHOVNDEHUHMHUDNWLHULDQGUHVHOVNDEHUG NNHUPDUNHGVY UGLHQGRJRYHU QRJHQGREEHOWUHJQLQJDIIRUPXHY UGLHUQH 'HDPHULNDQVNHDNWLHNXUVHUKDYGHWRSSHQRJHWWLGOLJHUHLPDUWVRJDXJXVW HQGGHGDQVNHDNWLHNXUVHU'HWWHIUHPJnUDIGLDJUDPVRPYLVHULQGHNVHW6WDQGDUG 3RRUVVDPPHQPHGGHWGDQVNH.$;LQGHNV6 3G NNHUVWRUH 86$YLUNVRPKHGHU 'HWIRUKROGDWGHGDQVNHDNWLHUWRSSHGHVHQHUHHQGGHDPHULNDQVNHNDQWRONHVVRP LGpHNVSRUWIUD86$WLO'DQPDUNDIGHWVWRUHVNLIWIUDRSWLPLVPHIDVHWLOSHVVLPLVPH IDVHYHGU UHQGHDNWLHNXUVHUQH 'HULPRGV\QHVGHPnQHGOLJHNXUVXGVYLQJV\QHVDWY UHNRUUHOHUHGHLIRUEO IIHQGH JUDG'RJWRJRSVYLQJHWHIWHUVHSWHPEHUO QJHUHWLGL'DQPDUN%HJJH LQGHNVHUQRPLQHOOHPHGHQEDVLVMXVWHUHWWLO1LYHDXIRUVNHOOHQHUQDWXUOLJ RJE ULNNHRYHUIRUWRONHV )UHPODJWSn'HQQRUGLVNH NRQRPLVNLGpKLVWRULVNHNRQIHUHQ HLROGH 1RUJHPDMPHGV UOLJY JWSnEHJUHEHUQHNRQYHQWLRQHURJRYHUEHYLV QLQJHUVRPHU HQWUDOHELGUDJL.H\QHV*HQHUDO7KHRU\8QGHUV JHOVHQHUL YULJW LQVSLUHUHWDISURIHVVRUYHG. EHQKDYQV8QLYHUVLWHW-DNRE%U KQHUDGVHQV SLRQHUIRUVNQLQJ YHGU UHQGH VDPPHQK QJHQH PHOOHP DNWLNXUVHU RJ PDNUR NRQRPLHQ%nGHGHQWHRUHWLVNHPRGHORJGHQHPSLULVNHWHNQLNHUGRJKHOW PLQHHJQH

4 'LDJUDP'DQVNHDNWLHNXUVHUMDQXDUDSULO.$;PnQHGVLQGHNVMXVWHUHWWLOnUVJHQQHPVQLW 1RWH.$; LQGHNVHW WRSSHU MDQXDU PHG LQGHNVY IHEUXDU YHG LQGHNVY UGL.LOGH 'DQPDUNV 6WDWLVWLN 6WDWLVWLNEDQNHQ UGL 'HQ IRUHO ELJH EXQG QnV

5 'LDJUDP6 3YLVWVDPPHQPHGGHWGDQVNH.$;LQGHNV -DQXDUDSULO%HJJHLQGHNVMXVWHUHWWLO 1RWH 6 3 WRSSHU DXJXVW PHG LQGHNVY UGLHQ.$; WRSSHU QRJHW VHQHUH L MDQXDU PHG LQGHNVY UGLHQ.LOGHU 86$ DNWLHNXUVHU 6WDQGDUG 3RRUV KMHPPHVLGH VDPW KMHPPHVLGHQ <DKRR )LQDQFH KYRU GH KLVWRULVNH VHULHU NDQ ILQGHV'HW GDQVNH.$; LQGHNV 'DQPDUNV 6WDWLVWLN 6WDWLVWLNEDQ NHQ

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³SRVWLQGXVWULHOOH SHULRGHHIWHUPLGWHQDIHUQH 'HQEDVDOHNDSLWDOY UGLHUVnOHGHVIULJMRUWIUDRSWLPLVPHSHVVLPLVPHIDVHUQH (QSDUDEHO RPHQIULP UNHVDPOHU NRQRPL 6S UJVPnOHWRPNDSLWDOY UGLHUQHVNRQYHQWLRQHOOHJUXQGODJRJEHW\GHOLJHXDIK Q JLJKHGDIPXOLJHNRUULJHUHQGHPDUNHGVPHNDQLVPHUNDQEHO\VHVPHGHQIRUW OOLQJ RPHQIULP UNHVDPOHU NRQRPL )ULP UNHVDPOHUQHKDUVDPOLQJHUDIIRUVNHOOLJWRPIDQJRJVDPPHQV WQLQJ'H KDQGOHULYULJWLQGE\UGHVVnOHGHVDWGHHQNHOWHVDPOLQJHURYHUWLGHQNDQXQGHUJn VWRUH QGULQJHU +DQGOHQ NRRUGLQHUHV DI HW NDWDORJXGYDOJ 8GYDOJHW SULVV WWHU GH IRUVNHOOLJH P UNHURJ QGUHUO EHQGHSULVV WQLQJHQVnOHGHVDWGHUHODWLYHSULVHUHUOLJHY JWV SULVHU)RUDWOHWWHRPV WQLQJHQGULYHUNDWDORJXGYDOJHWHQ OHDULQJ HQWUDO+HU UHJLVWUHUHVWLOJRGHKDYHQHURJJ OGLIRUELQGHOVHPHGKDQGOHUPHOOHPVDPOHUH 7LOJRGHKDYHQHUDIYLNOHVYHGHIWHUI OJHQGHN ERJJ OGDIYLNOHVYHGVDOJDI IULP UNHUWLODQGUHVDPOHUH&OHDULQJ HQWUDOHQPXOLJJ UIOHUVLGHGHKDQGOHUGHUHU PHUHVDPPHQVDWWHHQGWRVLGHGHE\WWHKDQGOHU.DWDORJXGYDOJHWV JHUDWEHVWHPPHUHODWLYHSULVHUGHUVYDUHUWLOGHQYHNVOHQGH LQWHUHVVHIRURJVM OGHQKHGDIIULP UNHUQH)RUDWXQGJnDW OHDULQJ HQWUDOHQ 8GWU\NNHW³SDUDEHO HULQVSLUHUHWDI.H\QHV NHQGWHSDUDEHORPHQEDQDQSUR GXNWLRQV NRQRPLL$7UHDWLVHRQRQH\YRO,SS

7 NRPPHULYDQVNHOLJKHGHULIRUPDIDWOnQWDJHUQHLNNHYHGVDOJDIIULP UNHUNDQ LQGIULJ OGHQWLOVWU EHUNDWDORJXGYDOJHWHQYLVLQIODWLRQLNDWDORJSULVHUQH.DWDORJSULVHUQH KDUHQQRUPDWLYIRUELQGHOVHWLOSULVHUQHLGHQVWRUHUHDO NRQRPL XGHQIRUIULP UNHVDPOHUQHVYHUGHQ)LQGHUNDWDORJXGYDOJHWRJIULP UNHVDPOHUQH JHQHUHOWDWHWIULP UNHHUHQHVWnHQGHEHW\GQLQJVIXOGWDIVSHMOHVGHQQHYXUGHULQJ LHQPHJHWK MNDWDORJSULVLGHQRPJLYHQGH NRQRPLVSHQJH 'HQQHIULP UNHVDPOHU NRQRPLNDQLODQJHSHULRGHUOHYHVLWHJHWOLYXDIK QJLJW DW GHQ VWRUH RPJLYHQGH UHDO NRQRPL.DWDORJSULVHUQH NDQ VWLJH VW W RJ GHQ UHJLVWUHUHGHNDWDORJY UGLDIVDPOLQJHUQHNDQQnVWRUHSHQJHEHO E 1XVNHUGHWWULVWHDWHMHUHQDIHQVWRUIULP UNHVDPOLQJG U$UYLQJHUQH QVNHUDW UHDOLVHUHGHQEHW\GHOLJHSHQJHY UGL6DPOLQJHQNDQNXQV OJHVWLOHQVWRUVDPOHU HOOHUWLOHQNUHGVDIDQGUHIULP UNHVDPOHUH$UYLQJHUQHVNDOEHWDOHVLGHQRPJLYHQ GH NRQRPLVULJWLJHSHQJH 'HUHUQXIDUHIRUDWIULP UNHSULVEREOHQSXQNWHUHV)ULP UNHVDPOHUQHPnGLVSR QHUHRYHUULJWLJHSHQJHLIRUQ GHQWRPIDQJRJGHPnY UHYLOOLJHWLODWEUXJHGHP SnIULP UNHN E6LWXDWLRQHQUHGGHVKYLVGHWHUPXOLJWIRUGHVWRUHIULP UNHVDP OHUHO EHQGHDWV OJHIULP UNHUIRUULJWLJHSHQJHWLOVPnVDPOHUHXGHQIRUGHVWRUH VDPOHUHVNUHGV'HSHQJHEHO EGHUDNNXPXOHUHVSnGHQQHPnGHNDQE UHDWGHU OHMOLJKHGVYLVVNHUHQUHDOLVHULQJDISHQJHY UGLHQDIHQDIGHVWRUHRJG\UHVDPOLQ JHU RUDOHQDIIRUW OOLQJHQHUDWHWY UGLSDSLUPDUNHGLQ DVXHWIULP UNHPDUNHG LPHJHWK MJUDGNDQXGYLNOHVLJXDIK QJLJWDIGHQRPJLYHQGHUHDO NRQRPLRJ DWPDUNHGHWVSULVHULQ DVXIULP UNHNDWDORJSULVHUQHNDQPnVWRUHK MGHU'HU HUGRJWRIRUPHUIRUIRUDQNULQJLGHQRPJLYHQGH NRQRPL L 1RUPHUVRPIRUELQGHUSULVHQSnIHNVHWPHJHWVM OGHQWIULP UNHPHG SULVHULGHQRPJLYHQGHUHDO NRQRPL+YLVIULP UNHWHUHQHVWnHQGHE UGHWVSULV HIWHUNDWDORJXGYDOJHWVRJVDPOHUQHVQRUPHUNXQQHM YQI UHVPHGSULVHQSnDQGUH HQHVWnHQGHJRGHU.RQYHQWLRQHUQHGHUEHVWHPPHUIULP UNHUQHVY UGLKDUVnOHGHV HWQRUPDWLYWJUXQGODJ LL 'HWIRUKROGDWHWXGWU NDISHQJHIHNVHIWHUUHDOLVHULQJDIHQVDPOLQJPn PRGVYDUHVDIHQWLOJDQJDISHQJHLIRUPDIN EXGHIUDDQJOHUGHQQHEDODQ H NRPPHUSULVHUQHXQGHUSUHV+YLVXGWU NNHWHUVPnEHO EVDPPHQOLJQHWPHGGHQ O EHQGHRPV WQLQJYLOSUHVVHWGRJLNNHY UHV UOLJWVWRUW'HUHNVLVWHUHUHQ

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nUDINRPPHQWDUHQXQGHUILJXUO QJHUHIUHPPHE UHMHUVNDEWLO YLUNVRPKHGHUSnJUXQGDIGHWLQWUDPDUJLQDOHDINDVWV\VWHPDWLVNJLYHHQDINDVWJUDG VW UUHHQGOnQHUHQWHQ(QIDNWLVNIRUVNHOPHOOHPDNWLHUVRJREOLJDWLRQHUVDINDVW NDQGHUIRUVHVVRPUHVXOWDWDIDWGHWO\NNHVDNWLRQ UHUQHDWRSQnQRJHWDIGHWWH PHUDINDVW(QDQGHQGHOIRUVYLQGHUVRP³RUJDQL]DWLRQDOVOD N LIRUPDIHNVWUD K MHGLUHNW UO QQLQJHUPYHGHMHUVNDEHWHURJVnIRUEXQGHWHQULVLNRIRUDW YLUNVRPKHGHQPnOXNNHPHGWDEDIDNWLHNDSLWDOHQVRPI OJH'HUHUVnOHGHVWDOH RPHQHMHUVNDEVULVLNRSU PLH 'HWHUKHQVLJWVP VVLJWDWVWDUWHPHGDWVHKYDGGHUEHVWHPPHUGHQODQJHOnQHUHQ WH7RNRQNXUUHUHQGHV\QSnGHQPDNUR NRQRPLVNHUHQWHGDQQHOVHNDQIUHPVWLOOHV SnI OJHQGHPnGH 7HRUL, 'HUIRUXGV WWHVHWSHQJHSROLWLVNUHJLPHGHUXQGHUVW WWHUIRUYHQWQLQJHU RPHQVWDELOLQIODWLRQVUDWHK 'HQODQJHQRPLQHOOHOnQHUHQWHU % IUHPNRPPHUVRPGHQUHQWHGHUVNDEHUOLJHY JW PHOOHPRSVSDULQJRJLQYHVWHULQJYHGHQHQW\GLJWEHVWHPWLQGNRPVW<! <! &<! U %,<! U % _U % &#RJ,#HUKHQKROGYLVIRUEUXJVIXQNWLRQHQRJLQYHVWHULQJVIXQNWLRQHQ)XQNWLR QHUQHHUEHWLQJHWDIGHQIRUYHQWHGHVWDELOHLQIODWLRQVWDNWK5HDOUHQWHQHUOLJGHQ QRPLQHOOHUHQWHU % PLQXVGHQIRUYHQWHGHLQIODWLRQVWDNWK

9 ,QGNRPVWHQ<! VYDUHUWLOHQEHVWHPWEHVN IWLJHOVHVJUDGRJIRUXGV WWHVLWHRUL, DWIUHPNRPPHVRPUHVXOWDWDIQ UPHUHGHILQHUHGH NRQRPLVNHPHNDQLVPHU 5HDOUHQWHVDWVHQU % KHUV\VWHPHWVQDWXUOLJHUHQWHRJV\VWHPHWKDUNXQpQ QDWXUOLJUHQWHVDWV 7HRUL,,,GHQQHWHRULHUGHULNNHpQPHQPDQJHUHQWHVDWVHUGHUHULRYHUHQVWHP PHOVHPHGV\VWHPOLJHY JW /nqhuhqwhqu %HUEHVWHPWDIGHWILQDQVLHOOHPDUNHGVUHQWHNRQYHQWLRQ1LYHDXHW IRULQYHVWHULQJVIXQNWLRQHQ, # #HUEHVWHPWDIUHDOLQYHVWRUHUQHVJUDGDIWLOWUR )RUDOWHUQDWLYHQLYHDXHUDIU %RJ, # #IUHPNRPPHUHWLQGNRPVWQLYHDX< <&<U %, # <U %_<,QGNRPVWHQ<KDULWHRUL,,VWDWXVDIWLOSDVQLQJVYDULDEHOGHUPXOLJJ UV\VWHPOLJH Y JWYHGDOWHUQDWLYHQLYHDXHUDIUHQWHNRQYHQWLRQRJUHDOLQYHVWRUWLOWUR 6DPVSLOOHWPHOOHPGHWILQDQVLHOOHPDUNHGVUHQWHNRQYHQWLRQRJUHDOLQYHVWRUHUQHV JUDGDIWLOWURHUSnYLUNVRPKHGVQLYHDXLOOXVWUHUHWPHGILJXU

10 )LJXU 6DPVSLOOHW PHOOHP YDULHUHQGH UHDOLQYHVWRU WLOWUR RJ YDULHUHQGH UHQWHNRQYHQWLRQHU 9DULHUHQGH UHDOLQYHVWRU WLOWUR LOOXVWUHUHV YHG DW GH HQNHOWH SURMHNWV MOHUV K MGH HU YDULDEHO PHG DINDVWIRUYHQWQLQJHUQH VDPW YHG GH JUn V MOHU VRP UHSU VHQWHUHU SURMHNWHU GHU YHG ODY WLOWUR XDQVHW DINDVWJUDG RSJLYHV DI NRQVROLGHULQJVKHQV\Q %HP UN DW GH LQWUDPDUJLQDOH SURMHNWHU KDU HQ K MHUH DINDVWJUDG HQG OnQHUHQ WHQ +HUDI NDQ VOXWWHV DW DNWLYW HMHUVNDE NDQ IRUYHQWHV V\VWHPDWLVN DW JLYH HQ K MHUH DINDVWJUDG HQG OnQHUHQWHQ 7HRUL,,UHSU VHQWHUHUGHQLQGVLJW.H\QHVYDUQnHWIUHPWLOL*HQHUDO7KHRU\QnU KDQVNULYHU ³7KHUDWHRILQWHUHVWLVDKLJKO\ RQYHQWLRQDOSKHQRPHQRQ *7S VDPW ³7KHVWDWHRI RQILGHQ HLVRQHRIWKHPDMRUID WRUVGHWHUPLQLJWKHLQYHVWPHQW GHPDQGV KHGXOH *7S )UHPVWLOOLQJHQ L *HQHUDO 7KHRU\ XGYLNOHV ODJ Sn ODJ 'HWWH HU IRUPRGHQWOLJ JUXQGHQWLODW.H\QHV Y UNIRUWRONHVVnIRUVNHOOLJW'HWR LWDWHUWLOK UHUGHWODJ KYRU.H\QHVIULJ UVLJVW UNHVWIUDGHQQHRNODVVLVNHWHRUL 'HWYLOGRJY UHHQRYHUIRUWRONQLQJDW.H\QHVQnHGHIUHPWLODWUHQWHGDQQHOVHQ XGHOXNNHQGHHUHWUHVXOWDWDINRQYHQWLRQHU5HQWHGDQQHOVHQHU³DKLJKO\ RQYHQWLR QDOSKHQRPHQRQ 'HWV\QVSXQNWYLIUHPI UHUQHGHQIRUHUDWUHQWHGDQQHOVHQNDQIRUVWnVPHGXGJDQJV

11 SXQNWL L NRQYHQWLRQHUGHUKDUNDUDNWHUDIQRUPDWLYHVNDEHORQHUVRPNDQIRUVWnV XGIUDGHILQDQVLHOOHLQYHVWRUHUVQRUPHU LL DWGHULGLVVHNRQYHQWLRQHULQGV WWHVIRUYHQWHGHVW UUHOVHURJDWUHQWHQ DOOHUHGHDIGHQQHJUXQGNDQYDULHUHRYHUWLGHQ LLL DW GHQ NRQYHQWLRQHOW EHVWHPWH UHQWH LNNH XPLGGHOEDUW NRUULJHUHV DI PDUNHGV NRQRPLVNHPHNDQLVPHUM YQI UWHRUL,, LY DWGHQNRQYHQWLRQHOWEHVWHPWHUHQWHGRJSnVLJWSnYLUNHVDIUHDO NRQRPL HQVWLOVWDQG.RQYHQWLRQHUQHVQRUPDWLYHNHUQHHUGHILQDQVLHOOHLQYHVWRUHUVIHNVSHQVLRQVNDV VHUVIRUHVWLOOLQJRPGHQLGHHOOHUHQWH(QVnGDQUHQWHVDWVHULQIODWLRQVUDWHQKSOXV NRQRPLHQVUHDOHY NVWUDWHSU DSLWDJ & (QVnGDQUHQWHVDWVYLOPXOLJJ UHDWHQ QRPLQHOIRUPXHRSVSDUHWIHNVPHGKHQEOLNSnSHQVLRQHULQJYLOEHYDUHHQN EH NUDIWGHUHUYRNVHWLWDNWPHGGHQUHDOHJHQQHPVQLWVLQGNRPVW 'HWEHP UNHVDWLHQ NRQRPLXGHQLQIODWLRQRJXGHQY NVWYLOGHQQHUHQWHY UH QXOLRYHUHQVWHPPHOVHPHGRSIDWWHOVHQDIGHQUHWI UGLJHUHQWHKRV$ULVWRWHOHV L%LEOHQRJL.RUDQHQ 'HILQDQVLHOOHPDUNHGHUVDNWXHOOHUHQWHNRQYHQWLRQYLOY UHEDVHUHWSnGHDNWXHOOH ODQJVLJWHGHIUHPDGUHWWHGHIRUYHQWQLQJHUPHGKHQV\QWLOLQIODWLRQRJY NVW 'HWJLYHUPHQLQJDWWDOHRPODYUHQWHKHQKROGVYLVK MUHQWHPnOWLIRUKROGWLOGH EDJXGUHWWHGHKLVWRULVNHHUIDULQJHUPHGKHQV\QWLOLQIODWLRQRJY NVW 'HQDNWXHOOHUHQWHNRQYHQWLRQVSLOOHUVDPPHQPHGUHDOLQYHVWRUHUQHVDNWXHOOHJUDG DIWLOWUR)RUVNHOOLJHNRPELQDWLRQHUHUYLVWLWDEHOVRPRJVnLOOXVWUHUHUIDVHU+/ RJ/+VRPNDQIRUYHQWHVDWI UHWLOHQUHYLVLRQLKHQKROGYLVRSDGJnHQGHRJ QHGDGJnHQGHDIUHQWHNRQYHQWLRQHQ

12 7DEHO )LQDQVLHOOH PDUNHGV UHQWHNRQYHQWLRQ /$9 (', (17( 5HDOLQYHVWRUHUQHV + - 7,/752 +/ + ++ RYHUEHYLVQLQJHU /$9 7,/752 // / /+ 1RWH LQGVWHNUDYHW WLO + - 7,/752 GHILQHUHV VnOHGHV DW IDVH + LQGHE UHU IXOG EHVN IWLJHOVH )DVHQ +/ I UHU WLO DNWLYLWHWVSUHV RJ WLO HQ UHYLVLRQ DI UHQWHNRQYHQWLRQHQ GYV WLO IDVH + HOOHU ++ )DVHQ /+LQGHE UHU ODY DNWLYLWHW RJ IRUXGV WWHV DW I UH WLO HQ UHYLVLRQ DI UHQWHNRQYHQWLRQHQ GYV WLO IDVH // HOOHU / )DVHQ // NDQ Y UH ODQJYDULJ M YQI U GHQ MDSDQVNH NRQRPLV QXY UHQGH WLOVWDQG (QWHRULRPHQYLUNVRPKHGVNDSLWDOY UGL (Q YLUNVRPKHGV NDSLWDOY UGL NDQ LNNH EHVWHPPHV VRP VXPPHQ DI DIKROGWH LQYHVWHULQJHUPHGIUDGUDJDIWHNQLVNHDIVNULYQLQJHU'HWWHLQGVHVOHWYHGDWRYHUYH MHDWEHVWHPPHNDSLWDOY UGLHQDIVHOVNDEHUVRPL URVRIW&R D&ROD6$6RJ 1RUGLVN1RYRPHGHQVn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nQHNDSLWDOEHVNULYHVPHG$ W #V#G +HQO JJHOVHUEHVNULYHVPHG. W #G 6RP XGJDQJVSXQNWIRUXGV WWHVKHQO JJHOVHUQHDWY UHQXO 'HQUHSU VHQWDWLYHYLUNVRPKHGNDQLNNHIRUXGV WWHVDWYRNVHLWDNWPHG NRQRPL HQ VRP KHOKHG 'HQ UHSU VHQWDWLYH YLUNVRPKHGV IRUYHQWHGH UHDOH Y NVWUDWH EHWHJQHVJ 5 'HQIRUYHQWHGHQRPLQHOOHY NVWUDWHHUJ 5 K'HWEHW\GHUDW $ W #VIRUYHQWHWYRNVHUPHGJ 5 KKYRU$ W IRUYHQWHWYRNVHUPHGJK 6RPXGJDQJVSXQNWPnDNWLRQ UHUQHIRUYHQWHDWHMHUDQGHOHQDIPDNUR NRQRPLHQV EUXWWRRYHUVNXGIDOGHURYHUWLGHQEODIRUGLGHUNRPPHUQ\HYLUNVRPKHGHUWLO GHUIRUE UIRUYHQWQLQJHQY UHDWJ 5 J

13 $NWLRQ UHUQHVNRQYHQWLRQPHGKHQV\QWLOQRPLQHOWDNWLHDINDVWHUU $.RQYHQWLRQHQ HUEDVHUHWSnHQQRUPDWLYVNDEHORQ6HWIUDIHNVSHQVLRQVNDVVHUQHVVLGHYLOGHW LGHHOOHDINDVWXGJ UHVXPPHQDILQIODWLRQVWDNWHQ NRQRPLHQVY NVWUDWHSU DSLWD VDPWHQSU PLHIRUDNWLYWHMHUVNDE'HWRI UVWQ YQWHVW UUHOVHUHUIRUYHQWQLQJHU 3U PLHQIRUHMHUVNDEHULVLJVHOYHQNRQYHQWLRQ'HWNDQIRUXGV WWHVDWU $!J 5 K HGGHGHUPHGGHILQHUHGHEHJUHEHUEHVWHPPHVYLUNVRPKHGHQVNDSLWDOY UGLSn WLGVSXQNWWVRPGHQWLOEDJHGLVNRQWHUHGHIRUYHQWHGHLQGNRPVWVWU P. W $ W #V#G. W #G #J 5 K U $. W $ W #V#G. W #G U $ J 5 K. W #U $ J 5 K $ W #V#G. W #G. W $ W #V#G U $ J 5 KG %HP UNDWWHUHWKLVWRULVNWLGVSXQNWRJDW-EHVNULYHUGHWIRUYHQWHGHWLGVSHUVSHN WLYGHUIUD,GHQUHVXOWHUHQGHIRUPHOHU$ W #VHWIRUHOLJJHQGHGDWXP$I VNULYQLQJHUQHG RJKHQO JJHOVHUQHG HUSUDNVLV'HULPRGHUU $ HQNRQYHQWLRQ RJJ 5 KIRUYHQWQLQJHU'HWIUHPJnUDIDWNDSLWDOY UGLHQHUVW UNWI OVRP IRU QGULQJHULU $ J 5 KHIWHUVRPG VRPXGJDQJVSXQNWHUIRUXGVDWDWY UH QXOM YQI UGRJQHGHQIRU 'HQVSH LILNNHGLIIHUHQ HU $ J 5 KVWDELOLVHUHVDIDW QGULQJHUL NRQRPLHQV JHQHUHOOHY NVWUDWHRJLQIODWLRQVWDNWEXUGHJLYH QGULQJHULU $ VRPWLOQ UPHOVHV YLVWXGOLJQHVDI QGULQJHUQHLJ 5 K,QGHQIRUHQO QJHUH NRQRPLSHULRGHPHG VWUXNWXUHOOHI OOHVWU NVRPIHNVGHQ³SRVWLQGXVWULHOOH SHULRGHIUDPLGWHQDI HUQHWLOLGDJEXUGHU $ J 5 KYXUGHUHVDWY UHNRQVWDQW'HQQHDQWDJHO VHNDQEHQ\WWHVVRPJUXQGODJIRUEHUHJQLQJDIGHEDVDOHNDSLWDOY UGLHU,PLGOHUWLGIRUHNRPPHUGHULQGHQIRUGHQQ YQWHO QJHUH NRQRPLSHULRGHSHVVL PLVPHRSWLPLVPHIDVHUYHGU UHQGHGHQUHSU VHQWDWLYHYLUNVRPKHGVY NVWUDWHJ 5 UHODWLYWWLO NRQRPLHQVVDPOHGHY NVWUDWHJ7LOVYDUHQGHNDQGHUW QNHVIDVHYLVH QGULQJHULNRQYHQWLRQHQYHGU UHQGHHMHUVNDEVULVLNRSU PLHQVRPLQGJnULGHQ QRUPDWLYHVNDEHORQIRUU $ 'HWWHNDQPHGI UHVWRUHXGVYLQJLU $ J 5 KPHG

14 EHW\GHOLJHIDVHYLVHNRQVHNYHQVHUIRUDNWLHNXUVHUQH )DVWKROGHOVHDIHMHUDQGHO 'HWYDUIRUXGV WQLQJHQRYHQIRUDWGHQUHSU VHQWDWLYHYLUNVRPKHGVRPXGJDQJV SXQNWYRNVHGHPHGHQUHDOY NVWUDWHJ 5 PLQGUHHQG NRQRPLHQVVDPOHGHUHDOH Y NVWUDWHJ(MHUDQGHOHQV - HUGDHQNYRWHKYLVW OOHUYRNVHUPHGUDWHQJ 5 KRJ KYLVQ YQHUYRNVHUPHGUDWHQJKKYRUDII OJHUDW - V - V#J 5 KJK 9LUNVRPKHGHQNDQNRPSHQVHUHIRUGHQIDOGHQGHHMHUDQGHOYHGLQYHVWHULQJHUL YLUNVRPKHGHQHOOHUYHGN EDIVXSSOHUHQGHHMHUDQGHOHLIRUPDIDNWLHULDQGUH YLUNVRPKHGHU $ W #VYRNVHUPHGJ 5 KKYRU$ W YRNVHUPHGJK. EHVGHUVXSSOHUHQGH HMHUDQGHOHIRU. W #JJ 5 K YHVGHQUHDOHY NVWUDWHDI$ W #VSURSRUWLRQDOW WLOJ 'HVXSSOHUHQGHHMHUDQGHOHNDQILQDQVLHUHVYHG JHGHKHQO JJHOVHU G JJ 5.DSLWDOY UGLHQ. W IRUEOLYHUX QGUHWDIGHIRU JHGHKHQO JJHOVHUGHULQYHVWHUHV VnGHURSQnVHQVW UUHY NVWUDWHJ. W $ W #V#G U $ JKG JJ 5 $ W #V#G U $ J 5 KG (MHUQHRSQnUDWIDVWKROGHHQHMHUDQGHOSnVRYHUWLGHQPHQUHGX HUHUGHQO EHQGH LQGNRPVWVWU PPHGGH JHGHKHQO JJHOVHU. W # G $NWLHLQGHNV (WDNWLHLQGHNVHULSULQ LSSHWIRUKROGHWPHOOHPHQSRUWHI OMHDNWLHUVPDUNHGVY UGL SnWLGVSXQNWWRJGHVDPPHDNWLHUVPDUNHGVY UGLLEDVLVnUHW2YHUWLGHQDIQRWHUHV QRJOHYLUNVRPKHGHURJGHUQRWHUHVQ\HYLUNVRPKHGHUSnDNWLHE UVHQ'HWPHGI UHU DWEDVLVJUXQGODJHWPnUHNRQVWUXHUHVPHGXGJDQJVSXQNWLGHDNWXHOWQRWHUHGHDNWLHU 'HWPHGI UHUDWLQGHNVYLUNVRPKHGHQNDQEHWUDJWHVVRPUHSU VHQWDWLYIRUGH DNWXHOWQRWHUHGHYLUNVRPKHGHU

15 , W $ W % 8GJDQJVSXQNWHWIRUEHUHJQLQJHQRYHQIRUDINDSLWDOY UGLHQDIHQUHSU VHQWDWLY YLUNVRPKHGYDUDWYLUNVRPKHGHQVRPXGJDQJVSXQNWKDYGHHQEHVWHPWHMHUDQGHO VDI NRQRPLHQVEUXWWRSURILW )RUDWNDSLWDOY UGLHQ. W VNDOY UHNRPPHQVXUDEHOPHGDNWLHLQGHNV, W HUGHW Q GYHQGLJWDWIRUXGV WWHDWGHQUHSU VHQWDWLYHLQGHNVYLUNVRPKHGJHQQHPKHQO J JHOVHURSUHWKROGHUHQNRQVWDQWHMHUDQGHODIGHQVDPOHGH NRQRPL'HWIRUXGV WWHV DWQRWHUHGHYLUNVRPKHGHUVYDUHQGHWLOHWEHVWHPWEDVLVY JWEHO E% RSUHWKROGHU HQNRQVWDQWHMHUDQGHOLNUDIWDIHJHQY NVWRJHYHQWXHOOHN EDIDQGUHVHOVNDEHU 'DQVNHDNWLHNXUVHURJEDVDOHNDSLWDOY UGLHU $NWLHNXUVHUQHYHGU UHU. EHQKDYQV)RQGVE UVRJHUEDVHUHWSnGH LQGHNVVRPHUSXEOL HUHWDI'DQPDUNV6WDWLVWLN 'HEDVDOHNDSLWDOY UGLHUEHUHJQHVSnJUXQGODJDIPHGIRUXGV WQLQJHUQH L DWEHUHJQLQJHQSnKYHUWWLGVSXQNWWYHGU UHUHQUHSU VHQWDWLYYLUNVRPKHG PHGVDPPHEHVWHPWHHMHUDQGHOV LL DWU $ J 5 KG WLOO JJHVHQNRQVWDQWY UGLGHUHUUHSU VHQWDWLYIRU SHULRGHQVRPKHOKHG6W UUHOVHQDIU $ J 5 KG HUGRJXNHQGW (QGYLGHUHDQWDJHVG DWY UHX QGUHWRYHUSHULRGHQ LLL %UXWWRSURILWWHQ$ W ILQGHVVRPVHULHLQDWLRQDOUHJQVNDEVVWDWLVWLNNHQXQGHU EHWHJQHOVHQ³EUXWWRRYHUVNXGDISURGXNWLRQRJEODQGHWLQGNRPVW 'HWDQWDJHVYLGHUHDWGHDNWXHOOHDNWLHY UGLHUJHQQHPQRJOHIDVHUOLJJHURYHURJ JHQQHPDQGUHIDVHUXQGHUGHGHUPHGEHUHJQHGHEDVDOHNDSLWDOY UGLHU2YHUGHQ O QJHUHYDUHQGH NRQRPLVNHSHULRGHDQWDJHVGHUDWY UHEDODQ HPHOOHPXGVYLQJH QHRYHURJXQGHUGHEDVDOHY UGLHU'HPHNDQLVPHUGHUVNDEHUEDODQ HHUDIGHQ NDUDNWHUGHUEOHYRPWDOWVRPNRQNOXVLRQSnSDUDEOHQRPHQIULP UNHVDPOHU NRQR PL 3nGHWWHJUXQGODJQRUPHUHVNDSLWDOY UGLHUQH. W VnOHGHVDWGHRYHUGHQODQJH SHULRGHSnnURSI\OGHU 6XEVLGL UWNDQPDQDQWDJHDWGHXQGHULRJLLQ YQWHSDUDPHWUHVRPLQGJnU LVDPOHWXGYLNOHUVLJPHGHQVWDELOWUHQGRYHUSHULRGHQ'HQQHDQWDJHOVHNU YHU HVWLPDWLRQDIWUHQGHQ

16 D W, W. W 'HGHUPHGQRUPHUHGHEDVDOHNDSLWDOY UGLHUEOLYHUGDGLUHNWHVDPPHQOLJQHOLJH PHGDNWLHNXUVLQGHNVHWLSHULRGHQ (QDOWHUQDWLYQRUPHULQJHU E W ORJ, W. W 1RUPHULQJHQESOD HUHUQLYHDXHWIRUEDVDOY UGLHUQHOLGWODYHUHLIRUKROGWLO GHIDNWLVNHDNWLHNXUVHUHQGQRUPHULQJHQD'HQI UVWHQRUPHULQJDJLYHU GHUIRUHQOLGWPHUHIRUVLJWLJYXUGHULQJDIGHK MHDNWLHNXUVHULHUQHHQGE (IWHUDWRSSHUDNWLHNXUVHUQHLYHGDIEDVDOY UGLHQ(IWHUE WRSSHUDNWLHNXUVHUQHYHGDIEDVDOY UGLHQ9LY OJHUGHUIRUSU VHQWHUH UHVXOWDWHUQHEDVHUHWSnGHQIRUVLJWLJVWHQRUPHULQJD 5HVXOWDWHUQHHUYLVWLGLDJUDPRJGLDJUDP'HWIUHPJnUDWGHULDQGHQKDOYGHO DIHUQHRJLEHJ\QGHOVHQDIHUQHKDUY UHWHQSHVVLPLVPHIDVHKYRU DNWLHNXUVHUQHKDUOLJJHWXQGHUEDVDOY UGLHUQHHUQHKDUEUDJWRSWLPLVPHIDVHU PHGDNWLHNXUVHURYHUEDVDOY UGLHUQH 8OWLPRDSULOHUDNWLHNXUVHQM YQI UGLDJUDP'HWHU DHQWUHGMHGHO RYHUEDVDOY UGLHQVRPNDQIRUXGV WWHVNXQDWKDYH QGUHWVLJOLGWIUDKYRU GHQHUEHVWHPWWLOM YQI UGLDJUDP

17 'LDJUDP'DQVNHDNWLHUVNXUVcUVJHQQHPVQLW %DVDOY UGLHUQRUPHUHWPHGD 1RWH cuhw HU DNWLHNXUVHQ RJ EDVDOY UGLHQ 8OWLPR DSULO YDU DNWLHNXUVHQ M YQI U GLDJUDP %HUHJQLQJVJUXQGODJ 1DWLRQDOUHJQVNDEVWDO 'DQPDUNV 6WDWLVWLN 6WDWLVWLNEDQNHQ $NWLHLQGHNV 'DQPDUNV 6WDWLVWLN 6WDWLVWLVN cuerj GLYHUVH nujdqjh VDPW 6WDWLVWLNEDQNHQ 7LO EHUHJQHGH 'DQPDUNV 6WDWLVWLN HJQH DNWLHNXUVLQGHNV Sn JUXQGODJ DI HW VWRUW XGVQLW DI GH QRWHUHGH VHOVNDEHU Sn. EHQKDYQV )RQGVE UV)UD EHQ\WWHU 'DQPDUNV 6WDWLVWLN )RQGVE UVHQV DNWLHLQGHNV'HW HU EDVHUHW Sn VDPWOLJH GDQVN UHJLVWUHUHGH VHOVNDEHU QRWHUHW Sn )RQGVE UVHQ%DVLV HU PHQ GHU VNHU HQ O EHQGH WLOSDVQLQJ DI Y JWJUXQGODJHW7LO EUXJ IRU GLDJUDPPHW HU DNWLHLQGHNVY UGLHU MXVWHUHW WLO

18 'LDJUDP$NWLHNXUVUHODWLYWWLOEDVDOY UGL cuvjhqqhpvqlw3ur HQWSRLQW %HUHJQLQJVJUXQGODJ 'DWDJUXQGODJHW IRU GLDJUDP